This site is built around one rule: every claim gets a credibility score, argued case by case, never templated. That's the part worth understanding before you dive in — so here's how it works, and a few places worth starting.

How the Scoring Works

Every case file on this site carries a numeric score out of 100 and one of six credibility stamps. The stamp isn't assigned by a formula — each case has its own "Why this stamp" section explaining the reasoning, weighing witness count, physical evidence, official corroboration, and how well mundane explanations hold up. The score is a judgment of how well a case holds up on its evidence, not a percent chance that anything was alien.

VERIFIED 4

Officially confirmed by a government body, sensor data, or multiple independent institutional sources.

CREDIBLE 40

Strong witness testimony and/or physical evidence, without full official confirmation.

DISPUTED 259

Genuinely contested — real evidence exists on more than one side of the explanation.

OPEN 39

Unresolved. Not enough evidence yet to lean toward any explanation.

DEBUNKED 28

A conventional explanation accounts for the case well enough to close it.

PERSONAL 4

First-person accounts, including the founder's own sighting — evaluated with the same honesty about limitations.

Most cases are also run through the Five Observables framework — the same set of anomalous performance characteristics popularized by AATIP's Luis Elizondo: anti-gravity lift, instant acceleration, hypersonic velocity without a heat/sonic signature, low observability, and trans-medium travel. A case doesn't need to show all five to be credible; most show one or two, if any.

Read a Book Breakdown

Four Essential Reading articles that pair directly with the figures above — full breakdowns of each book's core arguments, reception, and legacy.

Browse all 451 book breakdowns →

Browse the Case Files

Want to know why this site exists in the first place? Read the founder's story.