The Chulucanas Incident
On the evening of October 13, 2001, during Chulucanas's procession for the Señor Cautivo de Ayabaca, people in the streets reported orange lights in the sky over the town. Later accounts describe eight luminous spheres moving silently, joining and separating, for about two and a half hours (one 2013 account says more than five). Local cameraman Iván Iza filmed them. Investigator Anthony Choy, who began looking into the videos in February 2002 for the Peruvian Air Force's new anomalous-phenomena office (OIFAA), described "luminous red-orange craft 150 to 200 metres long" and an "apparently triangular" object. Further sightings and videos followed on October 25 and November 15, 2001. In February and March 2003 Choy appeared on Peruvian and international television alongside Colonel José Raffo Moloche, head of the Air Force's Directorate of Aerospace Interests, presenting the case as one under investigation within OIFAA. No written OIFAA report or statement on the case was ever issued, no independent analysis of the video has been published, and the sighting took place during a large festival whose possible pyrotechnics were never checked.
Bottom line
- Best explanation
- Still open. The obvious candidate, sky lanterns or fireworks released during the religious procession, was never checked; the reported duration and merging fit it poorly, but those details come from retellings. A planet cannot account for several moving lights.
- Why “Disputed”
- That a crowd saw lights and a cameraman filmed them is well attested. But the specifics, from the count to the size, come from one investigator’s summaries, the video was never independently analyzed, and the Air Force’s anomalous-phenomena office issued no written statement.
- What would change it
- Independent analysis of the full-resolution footage, a second recording of October 13, or any record of whether lanterns, flares or fireworks were used at the 2001 procession. None has surfaced.
Pictured: the entrance to Chulucanas, Piura Region, Peru — the town where the October 13, 2001 sighting occurred. This is not a frame from Iván Iza Nanfaro's original video or a photograph of the object itself; that footage has circulated only in low-resolution copies via Peruvian television broadcasts and OIFAA-affiliated researchers, and no rights-clear, publishable master copy is known to exist in the public record. This image is included solely to show the town named throughout this file.
Theoretical Alignment
Chulucanas scores moderately on the Extraterrestrial Hypothesis: the reported behavior — eight lights reportedly joining and separating for a long period — is not easily reduced to a single natural or celestial object, and a video exists, although it has never been independently analysed or released in full. The Psycho-Social score is kept meaningfully higher than in most files in this catalogue for an honest, case-specific reason: this sighting began in the middle of a large, emotionally charged religious procession, a setting well studied in the social-psychology literature for collective attention effects and shared suggestibility, and the object's own alleged behavior — zigzags and shapes that, in one blog's retelling, seemed to "want to" say something — is exactly the kind of pattern-seeking narrative a large, primed crowd can co-construct around an ambiguous stimulus. The Interdimensional Hypothesis finds little support; nothing in the core October 13 testimony describes portal-like or trans-dimensional behavior, only physically present lights that moved, combined, and departed.
Background
Chulucanas is a market and pottery town of roughly 80,000 people in Peru's Piura Region, seat of Morropón Province, sitting in the dry Piura Valley near the confluence of the Charanal and Piura rivers. It is internationally known for ceramics made using techniques descended from the pre-Incan Vicús and Tallán cultures, whose appellation of origin was requested in 2006 and registered in 2008. Every October 12–14, Chulucanas joins dozens of towns across the Piura region in observing the feast of the Señor Cautivo de Ayabaca, a devotion centered on an image of Christ whose making dates, by tradition, to a project begun in 1751 in the highland town of Ayabaca. It is one of the largest annual pilgrimages in northern Peru, drawing thousands to Ayabaca each October, and Chulucanas, which also counts the Señor Cautivo as a patron, held its own procession on October 13. In 2013 Peru's Ministry of Culture declared the festivity part of the nation's intangible cultural heritage (Resolución Viceministerial 063-2013-VMPCIC-MC).
Peru's Air Force (Fuerza Aérea del Perú, FAP) had no publicly known office for unidentified aerial phenomena before late 2001, despite earlier incidents such as the April 1980 La Joya encounter in Arequipa. According to Choy, the FAP formed the Oficina de Investigación de Fenómenos Aéreos Anómalos (OIFAA) in December 2001, within its Directorate of Aerospace Interests (DINAE); the office was later called DIFAA. A 2002 Miami Herald report described it as headed by FAP Commander Julio Chamorro with a seven-member team, and quoted him citing "the video taken in Chulucanas, Piura, at the end of 2001," which he said showed "a huge ship sitting in the sky for nearly two hours." Anthony Choy, a Lima lawyer who had studied UFO reports privately since 1999 and appears in a 2002 photograph of OIFAA's initial team, says that in February 2002 the office learned of the Chulucanas videos and that he travelled to the area. In April 2002 he delivered a detailed report to a special OIFAA committee. He describes Chulucanas as the first case studied by the Air Force.
Complete Timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 1999 | Anthony Choy, then a private researcher, begins independently studying UFO reports in Peru. |
| Mid-2000 | According to Choy, FAP pilots flying at 12,000 feet near Cerro Pilán see a huge "circle of fire" whose edges gave off a red-orange heat glow, 15 to 25 km across by their estimate; Choy cites it as regional precedent. |
| October 13, 2001, evening | During Chulucanas's procession honoring the Señor Cautivo de Ayabaca, attendees notice orange lights over the town; accounts describe eight spheres moving silently, joining and separating. |
| October 13, 2001 | Cameraman Iván Iza films the lights during the procession. The length of his footage is not documented in any source located. |
| October 13, 2001 | The display is reported to last about two and a half hours (Choy); a 2013 Foreign Policy account says more than five hours. |
| October 25, 2001 | Choy reports craft filmed near Cerro Pilán "landing in three different places" in the fields; Foreign Policy describes a bright, teardrop-shaped object about 80 feet long filmed near the town. No analysis of the ground sites has been published. |
| November 15, 2001 | Choy reports one of the craft "entering the city, coming down from the sky and causing panic," also filmed. |
| December 2001 | According to Choy, the Peruvian Air Force forms the Oficina de Investigación de Fenómenos Aéreos Anómalos (OIFAA) within its Directorate of Aerospace Interests (DINAE). |
| February–April 2002 | Anthony Choy, part of OIFAA's initial civilian team, learns of the Chulucanas videos in February 2002, travels to the area, and in April delivers a detailed report to a special OIFAA committee. |
| 2002–2005 | By October 2005 Choy has made 17 trips to the area over three and a half years, collecting what he later called about 80 hours of recordings, centred on Cerro Pilán. |
| February–March 2003 | Peruvian and international media cover the case: Panamericana's Reportajes (Feb 2), Telemundo's Al Rojo Vivo (Feb 28), RPP radio (Feb 25), América Televisión (Feb 27), Televisa (Mar 6), Reuters Television and Canal N. Choy and Colonel José Raffo Moloche, head of DINAE, are interviewed together on television, presenting Chulucanas as a case under investigation within OIFAA; no written statement is issued. |
| Mid-2004 | Rodolfo Cárdenas of Univisión's Colorado station contacts Choy; reporter María Rozman and chief cameraman Jesús Medellín arrive on August 4, 2004. |
| August 2004 | The Univisión crew, with Choy, films a light near the Moon from Piura La Vieja for about 55 minutes from 1:33 a.m., according to Choy, a separate event from October 2001. |
| 2008 | The FAP office is closed, reportedly because of "administrative problems" (UFO Insight). |
| 2013 | The FAP reopens the office as DIFAA, which Peruvian media report widely; former pilot Óscar Santa María Huertas's public account of the 1980 La Joya encounter is cited as part of the renewed interest. |
| 2014 | The British documentary series Invasion Earth (Pioneer Productions), shown on National Geographic channels, reconstructs the procession and Choy's investigation and describes Iván Iza as the photographer who filmed all three 2001 sightings. |
| 2005 onward | Choy presents Chulucanas as the first case of his "Proyecto 33," a survey of thirty-three documented cases across several fields, and says he has identified 23 zones of intense UFO activity covering about 75% of Peru. |
A Procession Interrupted
Every account of October 13, 2001 begins in the same place: the streets of Chulucanas, filled with the procession honoring the Señor Cautivo de Ayabaca. Blog and press retellings say that "hundreds" of the faithful were in the streets when they noticed lights in the sky; La República (2023) describes "eight orange spheres." Choy's own 2005 report speaks of "luminous red-orange craft 150 to 200 metres long floating in complete silence for two and a half hours" and captions a frame as an "immense, apparently triangular UFO." No individual attendee's account has been published, so the description rests on those summaries and on the video.
What distinguished the event from an ordinary transient light in the sky was its reported duration and behavior. The lights did not simply cross the sky; they are said to have stayed over the town, "joining and separating" (Expediente Oculto), with "zigzag" movements and shapes that seemed to "want to" express something (Espacio Blogs). Accounts of the duration differ: Choy and most retellings say about two and a half hours, the 2002 Miami Herald quotes the OIFAA head as saying the video shows a ship in the sky "for nearly two hours," and a 2013 Foreign Policy article says "over five hours." The sun set at about 6:10 p.m. local time; the Moon was below the horizon, and the brightest object in the evening sky was Mars, high overhead (JPL Horizons).
Iván Iza Nanfaro's Camera
The event's most consequential witness was Iván Iza (spelled "Ivan Isa Nanfaro" by La República), described as a cameraman filming the procession. Choy says that in February 2002 news reached OIFAA of "these videos that had been recorded by a Mr. Iván Iza," and La República reports that Choy later obtained copies of the footage for analysis, along with a second video filmed from a lookout on Cerro Ñañique. The 2014 documentary series Invasion Earth describes Iza as "the photographer who recorded videos of all 3 of the Chulucanas UFO sightings in October and November 2001." Earlier versions of this page called him a municipal employee, said he filmed "roughly 23 minutes," and said he later recorded "more than a dozen" further sightings; none of those details was found in any source.
What the footage still lacks is any independent analysis: no published frame-by-frame examination, no chain-of-custody record for the original tape, no published estimate of the lights' distance, and no full-resolution copy available for outside study. What has circulated publicly consists of broadcast copies. La República reports that Choy obtained copies of the footage for analysis, but no analysis by him has been published either. Whether Iza had any prior interest in UFOs, and whether he filmed by chance or because the lights were already attracting attention, is not recorded.
Formation, Fusion, Departure
The size figure most often quoted — 150 to 200 metres — comes from Choy, who applied it to "craft" in general and to an "apparently triangular" object in one frame; no method for it has been published, and with no known distance to the lights it cannot have been measured from the video. The accounts end with the lights converging into one and leaving, but no source located describes the end of the display in detail, and none reports any sound or physical effect.
Enter OIFAA: A Government Investigation Opens
According to Choy, the footage reached OIFAA in February 2002, about four months after the sighting. The office had been formed in December 2001, so there is no suggestion that the sighting prompted its creation. Choy, a member of its initial civilian team alongside FAP Commander Julio Chamorro and anthropologist Fernando Fuenzalida (as pictured in a 2002 Somos magazine report he reproduces), travelled to Chulucanas and in April 2002 handed a detailed report to a special OIFAA committee. That report has not been published.
What followed was, by Choy's own account, a sustained field investigation: 17 trips from Lima to the Chulucanas and Morropón valley over three and a half years to October 2005, and, he later said, about 80 hours of recordings. He came to regard Cerro Pilán, a hill outside the town long associated in local legend with lost people and livestock, as the "epicentre" of the activity, and by 2005 wrote that seven or eight sightings a week were being reported there. It was an investigation by one advisory researcher, not a multidisciplinary panel, and it has not been peer-reviewed. Chulucanas became the first case of what Choy calls "Proyecto 33," a survey of thirty-three documented cases across fields from UFOs to cryptozoology and parapsychology; separately, he says he has identified 23 zones of intense UFO activity covering about 75% of Peru.
Going Public: The 2003 Press Disclosure
The case reached the public in February and March 2003 through a run of broadcasts that Choy lists in his report: a 16-minute report on Panamericana's Reportajes on February 2 (repeated March 2), an interview on Radio Programas del Perú on February 25, an América Noticias report on February 27, a Telemundo report on Al Rojo Vivo on February 28, a Televisa report on March 6, a Reuters Television interview, and coverage in El Comercio, La República and Perú 21. On at least two programmes, including a live morning interview and Canal N's morning news in March 2003, Choy appeared alongside Colonel José Raffo Moloche, then director of the FAP's Directorate of Aerospace Interests (DINAE). In a 2008 interview Choy said that Raffo and he presented Chulucanas as "a case that was being investigated in Peru... within the sphere of OIFA," but acknowledged that "no hubo un comunicado oficial de la OIFA" — there was no official OIFAA statement — only a "media pronouncement through its most important representative at the time." The interviewer pointed out that the FAP had never issued anything official on the case. What Colonel Raffo said on air has not been transcribed in any source located.
What Choy Said About the Air Force's Role
In his September 2008 interview with Luis Vásquez for the Piura programme "Ruta de Ovnis," Choy was pressed on exactly this gap. The interviewer pointed out that "the Air Force has never issued an official communiqué" about Chulucanas, and asked whether Choy had fallen out with the FAP by going public. Choy said he had not: the Air Force "did not prevent my appearance in the media," but "on the contrary, supported everything I said, from start to finish, with the accompaniment of the highest official of the OIFA at that time." He described the case's public acknowledgment as coming "first" through the media, at his own initiative, and called it "a media pronouncement through its most important representative at that time" rather than an official statement. Asked about military secrecy, he said that within OIFAA "we had total freedom of information," that he "saw nothing" secret, and that any real military secrets would not have been in the hands of the civilian members. He also placed the office in a regional context: by his account Chile had opened a similar office in 1997 and Uruguay much earlier, in 1979, so that Peru was following rather than leading its neighbours.
The office's later history is only partly documented. UFO Insight reports that it was closed in 2008 because of "administrative problems." In October 2013 Foreign Policy and Peruvian media reported that the FAP was reopening it as the Departamento de Investigación de Fenómenos Aéreos Anómalos (DIFAA), which La República in 2023 described as having been "created in 2002 in response to an increase in UFO sightings," and for which, it said, Choy "worked for several years." None of these accounts cites an OIFAA or DIFAA document on Chulucanas, and no such document has been released.
The Aftermath Sightings and Cerro Pilán
Choy reports that the October 13 sighting was not isolated. Twelve days later, on October 25, 2001, he says craft appeared in the same area and "landed in three different places in the middle of the countryside," filmed on video; Foreign Policy describes the footage as "a bright, tear-shaped object about 80 feet long hovering near the city." On November 15, 2001, he says, "one of the craft entered the city, coming down from the sky and causing panic in the population," also filmed. No soil or other analysis of the reported landing sites has been published, and the November event rests on Choy's summary.
Choy's later research concentrated on Cerro Pilán. He cites legends that people and livestock have vanished there, a local historian's account of a reddish fireball that crashed toward the hill in 1902, a horseshoe-shaped bare patch of about 300 m² beside it, and pilots' reports from mid-2000 of a ring of fire 15 to 25 km across near the hill. He also reports witnesses who described two-metre-tall beings with slanted eyes in tight luminous suits, and a retired FAP pilot who said he had been taken aboard a craft near the hill in 1959. Local people told him, he says, that "the hills talk to each other... through balls of fire, spheres of light." These claims are recorded here as part of what has been said about Cerro Pilán; they rest on testimony collected years later, are not corroborated by the 2001 videos, and blend long-standing local legend with the UFO reports.
Choy's Own Sightings and Later Reports
Choy's first sighting of his own came on February 22, 2003, the night after a Telemundo crew had finished filming. Staying overnight in Piura La Vieja, a village of about 900 people then without electricity or running water, he joined some 40 residents in the main square at 9:23 p.m. to watch a small, distant light, twinkling and changing colour, move slowly and silently from the north-west toward Cerro Pilán at about 40° elevation, appear to stop over the hill and vanish at 9:28. The same thing happened at about 9:45 p.m., lasting a little under four minutes, and again at about 10:15, when the light passed the hill and stopped over Cerro Horquetudo. The sky was clear overhead and slightly cloudy near the horizon. Choy thought an aircraft or helicopter unlikely because of the silence, the repeated paths and the abrupt stops, but wrote that "some data deserve to be verified," including the distance, which he put at about 4 km without having checked it.
His 2005 report lists other sightings reported to him: on May 4, 2003, a group camping on the summit of Cerro Pilán saw a silent orange-red light pass at 3 a.m.; on August 19, 2003, at 10:32 p.m., "three strange balls of very powerful white light" stayed over Chulucanas "for 23 minutes," forming a kind of triangle, and were filmed; and on March 1, 2004, about 20 people near the hill watched a round orange-red light, "twice the size of the full Moon," move slowly from the direction of Chulucanas and stop over Cerro Pilán for about 20 minutes. The 23-minute figure that earlier versions of this page gave for Iván Iza's 2001 video may come from the August 2003 event; no source attaches it to the October 2001 footage. By October 2005 Choy wrote that the hill was producing an average of seven or eight sighting reports a week, though no permanent observation equipment had been installed to record them.
A Second Recording: The 2004 Univisión Expedition
The case's documentary record extended again in August 2004, when Rodolfo Cárdenas of Univisión's station in Denver, Colorado, sent reporter María Rozman and chief cameraman Jesús Medellín to film with Choy; they arrived on August 4. Working from Piura La Vieja, a village near Cerro Pilán, they saw a light moving toward the hill several times without the camera registering it. Later, according to Choy, Medellín was filming the full Moon when he saw something "below the Moon"; from 1:33 a.m. the object moved "up and down, left and right, like an impossible electrocardiogram," and was filmed for about 55 minutes. Choy says the camera battery died as the object vanished and that the event had been recorded on "3 tapes of 33 minutes" although they had only 60-minute tapes, and that the camera package was worth $60,000. Those technical claims come only from Choy's account. The event is separate from October 2001.
In 2014 the British-produced documentary series Invasion Earth (Pioneer Productions, shown on National Geographic channels) covered Chulucanas, with a dramatised reconstruction of the procession and of Choy's first journey to the town, and an interview with Iván Iza. An earlier version of this page said a National Geographic crew filmed its own unexplained light near Cerro Pilán during production and that a documentary titled El Incidente Chulucanas aired on March 8, 2014; neither claim was found in any source.
The Univisión Night in Detail
Choy's account of the Univisión trip is candid about its false starts. At 10:00 p.m. on the crew's first night of watching, a light appeared at about 45° above the horizon and moved toward the hill; it reappeared at 10:15 and 10:30, but the camera recorded nothing, and Choy himself suggested it might be a light aircraft circling over the summit. The main event came hours later, when the cameraman, who had decided to film the full Moon, saw something below it. As the object moved, someone in the group said it was "as if it were trying to write something" — the phrase that earlier versions of this page attributed to witnesses of the October 2001 procession. Rozman, Choy writes, said afterwards: "I saw something, I don't know what it was, something very strange." The resulting footage has not been independently analysed, and the night's first sightings, which Choy himself thought might be a plane, show how hard it is to judge a distant light from the ground.
How the Story Grew in the Retelling
The case's best-known figures are not stable from one account to the next. The earliest press report located, Lucien Chauvin's Miami Herald article of September 28, 2002, quotes OIFAA's head, FAP Commander Julio Chamorro, describing "the video taken in Chulucanas, Piura, at the end of 2001" as showing "a huge ship sitting in the sky for nearly two hours"; the same article says his seven-member office received hundreds of calls a month, about half of them sighting reports, of which about a dozen a month were credible, and that it had been "officially organized two years ago," which does not match Choy's December 2001 date. Choy's own report, written by October 2005 and published online in 2006, speaks of "craft 150 to 200 metres long" floating "for two and a half hours" and of an "apparently triangular" object. Later blog retellings (Expediente Oculto, 2008; Espacio Blogs) describe "eight luminous circles" or "eight luminous objects" joining and separating "in an intelligent way," and a 2013 Foreign Policy article says "hundreds of people observed eight spheres of red-orange light moving intelligently through the sky for over five hours." None of these accounts cites a named witness from the procession. The pattern — a single large ship in 2002, eight intelligent spheres by 2008, five hours by 2013 — is a reason to treat every specific number in this case as provisional until the original footage is examined.
Circumstantial Evidence
- "Hundreds" of people at a religious procession reportedly saw the lights on October 13, 2001; none has given a published individual account
- Cameraman Iván Iza filmed the lights during the procession; the length and quality of the footage are not documented
- An FAP colonel, José Raffo Moloche, appeared on television with Choy in 2003 while the case was presented as under OIFAA investigation
- No independent forensic video analysis, chain-of-custody documentation, or publicly released full-resolution master copy of Iza's footage has ever been produced.
- No formal written OIFAA report or findings summary was ever released; the only institutional confirmation on record is spoken, via 2003 press interviews.
- Follow-on October 25 and November 15, 2001 sightings, and a separate August 2004 filmed event, extend the case's documentary record but rest on testimony and video without independent physical or forensic corroboration.
- No radar, satellite, seismic, or other instrumented data corroborating the object's presence has been located in the public record.
Key Witnesses
Iván Iza Nanfaro
The case's central documentary witness: a cameraman ("camarógrafo," La República) who filmed the October 13, 2001 procession and the lights above it, and who is described in the 2014 series Invasion Earth as having filmed all three 2001 sightings. His footage prompted Choy's investigation. His employer and the length of the footage are not documented in any source located.
Anthony Choy
A Lima lawyer who has studied UFO reports since 1999 and was part of OIFAA's initial civilian team. He began investigating Chulucanas in February 2002, delivered a report to an OIFAA committee in April 2002, made 17 field trips over three and a half years, named Cerro Pilán the "epicentre," and presents Chulucanas as the first case of his "Proyecto 33." He is the principal on-record source for nearly every detail of the case.
Colonel José Raffo Moloche
Director of the FAP's Directorate of Aerospace Interests (DINAE), which housed OIFAA. He appeared alongside Choy in television interviews in early 2003, including Canal N's morning news, when the case was presented as under investigation within OIFAA. What he said on air has not been transcribed in any source located, and no written OIFAA statement was issued.
Procession Attendees (Unnamed Collective, Oct. 13, 2001)
"Hundreds" of people at the Señor Cautivo de Ayabaca procession are said to have seen the lights. No individual attendee has given a named, published account in the sources reviewed for this file, a real limitation given how large the witness pool is reported to have been.
The Five Observables Assessment
The Five Observables framework, developed by former AATIP director Luis Elizondo, is used across this catalogue to classify UAP encounters by performance characteristics exceeding known technology of their era. Applied to Chulucanas, the framework is constrained throughout by the case's total absence of any instrumented data beyond one video recording and collective eyewitness testimony:
Assessment: Anti-Gravity Lift is rated speculative: the lights reportedly stayed over the town for an extended period, a genuinely unusual capability if accurately described, but the claim rests entirely on visual impression rather than any instrumented measurement. Instant Acceleration is rated speculative on the same basis: the described repositioning among the eight lights suggests controlled movement, but no measurement of velocity or acceleration exists beyond witness impression and the video's own uncalibrated frame timing. Hypersonic Velocity is rated absent; nothing in any account describes the objects moving at extreme speed — the display's defining characteristic is a slow, sustained pace. Low Observability is rated N/A rather than present or absent, because Chulucanas is not a military installation and had no ground radar of any kind operating in its vicinity that night to test the objects against — a fundamentally different evidentiary situation from a base case like La Joya, where a real radar system's failure to acquire a visually obvious object is itself meaningful data. Trans-Medium travel is rated absent; no account describes any transition between air, water, or space.
Evidence Assessment
Supporting Anomalous Origin
- A large crowd reportedly saw the lights at the same time over a long period, although no individual accounts are published
- A contemporaneous video exists, filmed by a cameraman covering the procession
- The head of the FAP's Directorate of Aerospace Interests appeared on television with Choy while the case was presented as under OIFAA investigation, and OIFAA's head cited the video to the Miami Herald in 2002
- No conventional explanation has been tested against the footage or the festival record
Supporting Conventional Explanation or Testimonial Limits
- The case rests on a single primary video source; no second, independently filmed recording of the October 13 event by a different camera or vantage point has been located.
- No independent forensic or optical analysis of Iza's footage by a party outside OIFAA and Choy's own research circle has ever been published, and no full-resolution master copy is publicly available for outside re-examination.
- OIFAA never issued a written report or statement on the case; Choy's April 2002 report to an OIFAA committee is unpublished
- The sighting began inside a large, emotionally charged religious procession, a documented setting for collective-attention and pattern-over-attribution effects, which the Psycho-Social Hypothesis score above weighs honestly.
- Basic facts vary between accounts: the number and shape of the objects (eight spheres, or "craft 150 to 200 metres long," one "apparently triangular") and the duration (two, two and a half, or more than five hours)
Why "Disputed"
This file rates the Chulucanas Incident DISPUTED because the event itself is well attested but almost everything specific about it comes from one investigator. That a crowd at the October 13, 2001 procession saw lights, and that a cameraman filmed them, is supported by several independent retellings and by OIFAA's head citing the video in 2002. That the Peruvian Air Force treated the case as one of its first is supported by Choy's 2003 television appearances with the head of DINAE. But the specific claims — eight objects, 150–200 metres, two and a half hours, landings on October 25, a craft entering the town on November 15 — come from Choy's summaries; the video has never been independently analysed; OIFAA issued no written statement; and the obvious conventional candidate, lanterns or fireworks at a large religious festival, was never investigated. The accounts do not even agree on the duration.
Sensor & Instrumentation Detection Profile
This is, in instrumentation terms, an almost entirely visual and video-only case. Chulucanas in 2001 had no military installation, no civil aviation radar, and no scientific monitoring equipment of any kind operating in its immediate vicinity capable of independently tracking an aerial object; unlike La Joya Air Base's own ground radar, which is itself a meaningful (if negative) data point in that case, Chulucanas offers no comparable instrument record to check witness testimony against, positive or negative. The one piece of contemporaneous instrumented documentation is Iván Iza's video, whose length, equipment and format are not documented. No gun-camera-style telemetry, no timestamp metadata verification, and no independent optical or digital forensic analysis of the tape by a party outside Choy's own research circle has been published. The August 2004 Univisión expedition used broadcast camera equipment that Choy says was worth $60,000, and Choy has described technical anomalies during that filming (a battery draining unexpectedly, footage recorded across more tape than the cassette length should allow) — claims that, absent independent technical examination of the actual equipment and footage, this file records as reported rather than verified.
Environmental & Geospatial Context
Chulucanas sits at roughly 92 meters elevation in Peru's Piura Valley, part of the country's dry equatorial coastal-forest belt in the far north, a markedly different climate zone from the high Andean desert of La Joya or Arequipa further south. October falls within the region's dry season, but no weather record for the evening of October 13, 2001 was located. The sun set at about 6:10 p.m.; the Moon (12% lit) was below the horizon, Venus and Jupiter were below the horizon, and Mars (magnitude −0.2) was high overhead (JPL Horizons). Geologically, Piura lies within Peru's broader seismically active Pacific coastal zone, part of the Nazca Plate's subduction beneath South America, a tectonic setting later researchers have cited (though not specifically in connection with this case in any source this file located) as a possible source of natural luminous atmospheric phenomena in seismically active regions generally — a candidate explored further in this file's Conventional Explanation Candidate analysis below. Cerro Pilán itself, the focal point of the follow-on 2001 sightings and Choy's later research, is a hill in the countryside outside Chulucanas; Choy's base for visiting it was the village of Piura La Vieja, which he estimated at about 4 km from the hill.
Observer Credibility & Occupational Profile
The case's witness pool divides into tiers of quite different strength. The procession crowd is large but anonymous: no individual account has been published, so nothing can be said about any attendee's vantage point or credibility. Iván Iza is named and filmed the lights, but his own account has not been published either. Investigator Anthony Choy, a lawyer by training, made a sustained, multi-year field commitment (17 trips over three and a half years), but his investigation was never peer-reviewed, his April 2002 report is unpublished, and he is the source of most of the case's specific claims and of its more extraordinary extensions (landings, beings, a 1959 abduction). Colonel José Raffo Moloche's television appearances lend institutional weight, but nothing he said has been transcribed.
Physical & Material Assays
No physical trace, fragment, or recoverable material connected to the October 13, 2001 sighting itself has ever been documented, tested, or published — the spheres reportedly departed the area without any object descending to ground level during the core sighting. The case's closest approach to physical trace evidence comes from Choy's report that craft "landed in three different places" near Cerro Pilán on October 25, 2001, and from a horseshoe-shaped bare patch of about 300 m² he linked to a legendary 1902 crash. This file is obligated to note plainly that no published soil sampling, metallurgical assay, radiological survey, or other forensic physical analysis of these purported traces has been located in the available research record; the "landing" characterization rests on visual site inspection and witness description rather than any laboratory-tested physical evidence, a genuinely significant evidentiary gap given how central physical trace analysis has become to this catalogue's strongest cases elsewhere. No biological, electromagnetic, or radiological anomaly of any kind was reported in connection with either the October 13 sighting or its immediate aftermath.
Historical Precedents & Archive Matches
Within this catalogue, Chulucanas's closest institutional parallel is Peru's own La Joya Air Base Incident of April 1980, in which a Peruvian fighter pilot fired cannon rounds at a hovering object over an Arequipa air base — a case that, unlike Chulucanas, produced a genuinely independent declassified U.S. government cable but that the FAP itself suppressed internally for roughly two decades rather than acknowledging at the time, a contrast with Chulucanas, which was discussed on television within eighteen months with an FAP colonel present. Investigator Anthony Choy's involvement in both cases situates Chulucanas within a small, connected thread of Peruvian military-adjacent UFO investigation running from 1980 through the early 2000s and into OIFAA/DIFAA's ongoing, if intermittent, institutional life. More broadly, the case belongs to a documented pattern researcher Scott Corrales and the Journal of Hispanic Ufology have cataloged extensively: Latin American religious-festival UFO sightings, in which large, already-gathered crowds at patronal feast days, pilgrimages, or other mass religious observances report anomalous aerial phenomena at a substantially higher apparent rate than randomly distributed nights would predict — a pattern this file notes as a genuine avenue for future comparative research (do these events correlate with festival pyrotechnics, increased outdoor observation time, or a real independent phenomenon selectively drawn to gathered crowds?) rather than treating any single explanation as settled. Locally, the case also sits atop decades of pre-2001 folklore specific to Cerro Pilán itself — local traditions describing the hill as "encantado" (enchanted or haunted) and associated with unexplained disappearances long before 2001 — a genuine historical antecedent, though one whose supernatural framing predates and is analytically distinct from the specific UFO phenomenology Choy's investigation later documented there.
Material Analysis
Chulucanas is, in strict material-evidence terms, an almost complete evidentiary null set: despite a large crowd and a video recording, nothing physical connected to the display — no debris, no fragment, no ground disturbance, no residue — was ever recovered, tested, or published in connection with the core sighting itself. The only physical-evidence claim in the broader case file comes from the separate October 25, 2001 event, where investigators described apparent ground traces near three points outside Chulucanas, but as this file's Physical & Material Assays section above details, no laboratory testing of any kind has ever been published regarding these traces, leaving their nature — genuine anomalous mark, ordinary agricultural disturbance, or something else entirely — formally unresolved. The video itself, while a real and significant piece of documentary evidence, is not a physical trace in the forensic sense; without an independently examined master tape or file, it cannot currently support conclusions about the objects' true distance, size, or nature beyond what the original OIFAA-affiliated researchers themselves calculated.
Supporting Non-Terrestrial Origin
- Several lights reportedly staying over the town for hours and joining and separating is hard to reconcile with a single planet, meteor or satellite
- A large crowd and a video by a cameraman covering the procession establish that something was seen and filmed, independent of what it was
Supporting Terrestrial Origin or Testimonial Limits
- The absence of any independent forensic analysis of the video, combined with the total absence of a second independently filmed recording, means the case's strongest evidence has never been tested against alternative technical explanations by a party outside the original investigative circle.
- The event's origin within a large religious festival, where fireworks, sky lanterns, or other pyrotechnic displays are common at Latin American patronal feasts generally (though this file could not confirm the specific presence of such displays at Chulucanas's 2001 observance), leaves a mundane festival-related origin formally unruled-out rather than actively disproven.
The Conventional Explanation Candidate: Sky Lanterns & Festival Pyrotechnics
The most contextually obvious conventional candidate is also the one this file could least conclusively verify or rule out: some form of festival pyrotechnic display, whether traditional sky lanterns (hot-air paper lanterns lit and released to drift skyward), fireworks, or flares, released as part of the Señor Cautivo de Ayabaca observance itself. Patronal feast-day pyrotechnics are a well-documented feature of Latin American Catholic festivals generally, and the timing overlap — the sighting beginning during, not before or after, the procession — is exactly what this candidate would predict. No source located says whether lanterns, flares or fireworks were used at Chulucanas's 2001 procession, and no investigator appears to have asked. The candidate strains against the reported duration of two hours or more, far longer than a single lantern burns, though a festival releasing lanterns over several hours would produce a changing group of lights rather than the same eight. It also strains against the reported merging into one light. But the details that weigh against it (the count, the duration, the "formation") come from retellings rather than from published witness statements or an analysis of the video, so they cannot be relied on to exclude it.
Astronomical Misidentification (Venus, Planets, or Stars)
A second standard candidate for sustained, silent, colored lights is straightforward misidentification of a bright planet or star low on the horizon — On this evening, however, JPL Horizons shows Venus and Jupiter below the horizon, with Mars (magnitude −0.2) high overhead and no Moon. This candidate accounts reasonably well for the case's basic descriptive elements (a bright, sustained, colored point of light with no sound) but fails badly against the reported count and behavior: a fixed celestial object does not present as eight independently repositioning lights, does not shift its apparent formation over 150 minutes relative to the horizon in the manner described, and does not converge from eight points into one. This candidate might plausibly explain a small fraction of a large crowd's individual reports (some attendees may genuinely have glanced at Venus or another bright object independent of the main sighting) but cannot account for the core, video-documented multi-object display itself.
Atmospheric-Electrical or Tectonic-Strain Luminescence
Piura sits within Peru's broader seismically active Pacific coastal belt, part of the Nazca Plate's ongoing subduction beneath South America, and a scientifically documented (if still debated in its precise mechanism) natural phenomenon known as earthquake lights — luminous atmospheric displays associated with tectonic strain in quartz-bearing rock, most prominently studied by physicist Friedemann Freund and collaborators — has been observed in seismically active regions worldwide, including other parts of Peru during and preceding significant earthquakes. This file's research did not locate a documented seismic event specifically coincident with October 13, 2001 in the immediate Piura area, a real evidentiary gap for this candidate. Earthquake-light phenomena, as scientifically described, also typically present as diffuse glows, flashes, or streamers along fault-line features rather than as eight discrete, independently maneuvering, formation-holding spheres sustaining a coordinated display for 150 minutes — a significant behavioral mismatch that keeps this candidate from being a clean fit even where the region's tectonic setting makes it worth naming.
Sky Lanterns / Festival Pyrotechnics
InconclusiveThe timing during a large religious festival is suggestive and the candidate was never checked; the reported duration and merging fit poorly, but those details rest on retellings.
Astronomical Misidentification
ImplausibleVenus and Jupiter were below the horizon; Mars was high and moderately bright but cannot account for several moving lights.
Tectonic-Strain / Earthquake Lights
InconclusiveA scientifically real phenomenon in this seismic region, but no matching seismic event was found for the date, and the typical diffuse/streamer appearance doesn't match eight discrete formation-holding spheres.
Related Cases
Institutional Record
Colonel José Raffo Moloche, director of the FAP's Directorate of Aerospace Interests (DINAE), appeared on Peruvian television with Anthony Choy in early 2003 while the Chulucanas case was presented as under OIFAA investigation. Choy has said there was no official OIFAA statement. No written government document on the case has been located.
UNCLASSIFIED (no written document located)Search Government Archives Directly
Further Reading — Recommended Literature
The UFO Encyclopedia, 4th Edition
The definitive UFO reference work, useful for cross-referencing Chulucanas against the broader catalogue of Latin American military and civilian UFO cases.
Confrontations: A Scientist's Search for Alien Contact
Vallée's field investigations of Latin American UFO cases from a comparable era, offering methodological context for evaluating a mass-witnessed sighting investigated years after the fact.
Wonders in the Sky
A global historical catalogue of unexplained aerial phenomena, useful for situating Chulucanas's "multiple spheres converging into one" morphology against similar historical reports elsewhere.
Chupacabras: And Other Mysteries
By the founder of Inexplicata — The Journal of Hispanic Ufology, whose ongoing coverage of Latin American anomalous-phenomena cases, including Peru's, provides useful regional research context for this file.
Above Top Secret: The Worldwide UFO Cover-Up
A landmark survey of international UFO cases and government secrecy patterns, useful comparative context for evaluating how OIFAA's on-record-but-unwritten 2003 disclosure fits a broader global pattern of partial institutional acknowledgment.
DISCLOSURE: Some links above are affiliate links. If you purchase through them, OverClassified receives a small commission at no additional cost to you. This helps support independent research.
Essential Viewing
Anthony Choy Oficial: El Incidente Chulucanas — El Video del Aterrizaje OVNI
Investigator Anthony Choy's own official channel presents footage and analysis connected to the case's follow-on landing reports near Cerro Pilán.
Perú21TV: Anthony Choy Recounts a Chulucanas UFO Anecdote
A Peruvian news outlet's interview segment with Choy discussing his personal recollections of the Chulucanas investigation.
Curiosum Break: The First UFO Case Officially Studied in Peru — The Chulucanas Incident
A dedicated documentary-style overview of the case's history, the OIFAA investigation, and its place in Peruvian UFO research.
Sources
- "Perú: El Incidente Chulucanas (Parte 1)," MysteryPlanet.com.ar. mysteryplanet.com.ar
- "Perú: El Incidente Chulucanas (Parte 2)," MysteryPlanet.com.ar (2004 Univisión follow-up expedition). mysteryplanet.com.ar
- "Project 33, The Chulucanas Incident, And Peru's Official UFO Office," UFO Insight. ufoinsight.com
- "EL INCIDENTE CHULUCANAS," Expediente Oculto, February 2008. expedienteoculto.blogspot.com
- "LOS OVNIS DE CHULUCANAS," Expediente Oculto, September 2010. expedienteoculto.blogspot.com
- "El Incidente Chulucanas – Caso OVNI en Piura, Perú," Espacio Blogs. blogs.deperu.com
- "Ovnis en Chulucanas, Piura," Espacio Blogs. blogs.deperu.com
- Choy Montes, Anthony. "Crónica de un encuentro ovni en Chulucanas," RPP Noticias (Choy's own first-hand account of the August 2004 Univisión follow-up expedition). rpp.pe
- "ENTREVISTA AL DOCTOR ANTHONY CHOY MONTES PARA EL PROGRAMA 'RUTA DE OVNIS,'" Investigación Ovni en Perú, September 2008 (Choy interview discussing the Chulucanas case and OIFAA's institutional history, including the "no hubo un comunicado oficial" disclosure). ovniperu.blogspot.com
- "¿Sabías que la FAP tiene un departamento que investiga ovnis? Extrabajador revela detalles," La República, June 2, 2023 (OIFAA/DIFAA institutional history and Iván Iza Nanfaro's role). larepublica.pe
- "Cerro Pilán: cómo llegar al centro de avistamiento ovni en Piura y epicentro de misterios en Chulucanas," La República, July 7, 2023. larepublica.pe
- "Anthony Choy: El abogado que no podía dejar de mirar el cielo," Diario Correo. diariocorreo.pe
- "Anthony Choy, el ufólogo y abogado que buscaba historias y terminó fascinado por el tema OVNI," Infobae Perú, February 12, 2023. infobae.com
- "Anthony Choy," Wikipedia (Spanish). es.wikipedia.org
- "El enigmático cerro Pilán: misterio, desaparecidos, encantamientos y ovnis," Expreso, Peru. expreso.com.pe
- "Conoce los túneles y construcciones que 'desaparecen' en el cerro Pilán en Morropón," Walac Noticias. walac.pe
- "Conoce más de la historia del Señor Cautivo de Ayabaca," Walac Noticias. walac.pe
- "Señor Cautivo de Ayabaca," Wikipedia (Spanish). es.wikipedia.org
- "Señor Cautivo de Ayabaca, un camino lleno de fe," Infobae Perú, October 13, 2023. infobae.com
- "Chulucanas," Wikipedia. en.wikipedia.org
- "Chulucanas District," Wikipedia. en.wikipedia.org
- Corrales, Scott. "Peru: La Joya AFB, The Perfect UFO Case (1980)," Inexplicata — The Journal of Hispanic Ufology. inexplicata.blogspot.com
- YouTube oEmbed API verification records for video IDs f1sCZQKttpE, kJBGav7efTA, and INyVB69PQyo (Essential Viewing section sourcing).
- Wikimedia Commons. "Ciudad de Chulucanas, Piura PERÚ.jpg," photograph by Dmnltics Isabel Requena, CC BY-SA 4.0. commons.wikimedia.org
- National Archives (NARA). "UAP Textual and Microfilm Records Research Guide." archives.gov
- Choy Montes, Anthony. "Perú: El Incidente Chulucanas (Parte 1)," report dated October 2005, published by MysteryPlanet.com.ar on October 30, 2006 (source for the 2003 media appearances, Choy's own sightings and the later reports). mysteryplanet.com.ar
- Chauvin, Lucien O. "Peruvians seek discovery and profit in UFOs," The Miami Herald, September 28, 2002 (as reproduced by Patrick Gross). ufologie.patrickgross.org
- Treywick, Catherine A. "Peru's Air Force Opens a UFO Office, and It's Twitter-Friendly," Foreign Policy, October 29, 2013. foreignpolicy.com
- Invasion Earth (Pioneer Productions, 2014), episode gallery captions on Chulucanas, Anthony Choy and Iván Iza, via Wunschliste. wunschliste.de
- NASA/JPL Horizons System, observer ephemerides for 5.10°S, 80.17°W, 2001-10-13 23:00 to 2001-10-14 03:00 UT (Sun, Moon, Venus, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn). ssd.jpl.nasa.gov
Corrections (October 2026)
A check of the case's sources against Choy's own 2005 report, his 2008 interview, the 2002 Miami Herald report and later press found that the earlier version of this page stated several of the case's details more firmly than any source does, and attributed some details that no source supports. It described Iván Iza as a municipal employee who filmed "roughly 23 minutes" and later recorded "more than a dozen" sightings; none of these was found (the only 23-minute figure in Choy's report belongs to an August 2003 sighting). It said each of eight spheres was "150–200 meters across"; Choy applied that size to "craft" and to an "apparently triangular" object, with no published method. It said Colonel José Raffo Moloche "publicly confirmed" a formal investigation as the "first uniformed" Peruvian military spokesperson to do so; no transcript of his remarks has been found, and Choy himself says there was no official OIFAA statement. It said a British National Geographic crew filmed its own anomalous light during a documentary aired March 8, 2014; the 2014 production located is the series Invasion Earth, and no such crew sighting was found.
Following this review, the rating was changed from Disputed 51 to Disputed 38 (October 27, 2026), because the higher rating had rested partly on claims corrected or removed above.
Other corrections: Choy began investigating in February 2002 (not "January"), and delivered a report to an OIFAA committee in April 2002; "Proyecto 33" is a set of thirty-three documented cases, while the 23 zones covering 75% of Peru are a separate count; the "writing in the sky" description belongs to the 2004 Univisión night, not to October 2001; the 2003 broadcasts were led by Panamericana, Telemundo, RPP, América Televisión, Televisa and Reuters; the reported duration varies from "nearly two hours" to "over five hours"; the crowd is described as "hundreds," with no individual accounts; the ceramics appellation was requested in 2006 and registered in 2008. Removed: the "~7:00–10:00 PM" times, the clear-weather claim, the Venus candidate (Venus was below the horizon, per JPL Horizons), the 158–350 m height and 6 km access distance for Cerro Pilán, and computed airport and weather fields.
See something inaccurate? Have additional information or sources?
Suggest an Edit →Last Updated: October 27, 2026
