CASE FILE #355 DISPUTED Credibility32/100

The 1981 Chinese Spiral Mass Sighting

On the night of July 24, 1981, at about 22:38 Beijing time, a slowly rotating spiral of silvery light appeared over western and southern China. Xinhua reported sightings over Tibet, Beijing and at least twelve other provinces; a 1982 Chinese aerospace-magazine article claimed "some 10,000,000" witnesses, and later retrospectives say more than a million. Two Purple Mountain Observatory scientists, Liu Yan and Wang Sichao, analyzed the eyewitness reports. Liu concluded it was most likely produced by an artificial spacecraft at about 650 km, the kind of explanation later confirmed for Norway's 2009 "sky spiral" (a missile venting fuel), but no specific launch has ever been matched to this date. Wang, who studied the case for more than twenty years and said he believed in extraterrestrial life, did not accept a conventional resolution.

Bottom line

Best explanation
Very probably a rocket or spacecraft venting leftover propellant at high altitude, the mechanism confirmed for Norway’s 2009 spiral. It matches the case’s own data closely; an early meteor theory was tested against trajectory data and refuted.
Why “Disputed”
The two lead investigators, astronomers at the Purple Mountain Observatory, disagreed: one judged a spacecraft most likely, while the other, who studied the case for more than twenty years and was convinced extraterrestrials exist, did not accept a conventional answer. The actual rocket has never been identified.
What would change it
A specific launch matched to the date and the calculated track, a retrograde path inclined about 112° to the equator. A launch catalogue shows no orbital launch on July 22–25, 1981, and no radar data or verified photograph survives.
Date
July 24, 1981
Location
Western, southwestern and south-central China; Xinhua cited Tibet, Beijing and at least 12 other provinces
Craft Type
Anomalous Light — luminous rotating spiral
Witnesses
Unknown; claims range from “more than a million” (Chinese retrospectives) to “some 10,000,000” (Long Ruyi, 1982)
Evidence
Mass eyewitness testimony; institutional trajectory calculations; a handful of unrecovered blurred photographs; no radar record
Classification
CE1 (Visual, no physical interaction)
Time
About 22:38 Beijing Time (Long Ruyi: six or seven minutes); later Chinese retrospectives give 22:33–22:52; Xinhua reported sightings between 22:30 and 23:30 lasting one to ten minutes
Weather
Clear, cloudless night sky across the affected region
Purple Mountain Observatory (Zijinshan Observatory) in Nanjing, whose astronomers led the technical analysis of the July 24, 1981 spiral
View more photographs on Google Images →
View photographs on Google Images →

Pictured: the Purple Mountain Observatory in Nanjing — not a photograph of the spiral itself. The 1982 Hangtian article mentions "a few blurred photos" of the July 24, 1981 phenomenon, but no verifiably rights-clear copy of any of them is known to survive online today. This is a real photograph of the institution whose astronomers analyzed the eyewitness reports.

Theoretical Alignment

🛸
Extraterrestrial (ETH)
20% Alignment
🌀
Interdimensional (IDH)
10% Alignment
🧠
Psycho-Social (PSH)
5% Alignment

Low-to-moderate alignment with the Extraterrestrial Hypothesis. The case's own most persistent scientific investigator, Wang Sichao, said he was convinced extraterrestrials exist and did not accept a conventional resolution, and Chinese retrospectives built on his figures keep an ETH reading alive. Psycho-social explanations struggle against the geographic scale of simultaneous sightings. The dominant, best-evidenced reading is neither extraterrestrial nor psychological but conventional-technological: a human-made object, most likely a rocket stage or missile venting residual propellant at extreme altitude, of the kind confirmed for Norway's visually similar December 2009 "sky spiral."

Background

By the summer of 1981, the People's Republic of China was five years removed from the death of Mao Zedong and the end of the Cultural Revolution, and deep into paramount leader Deng Xiaoping's "Reform and Opening Up" era. Scientific and technical subjects that had been politically dangerous a decade earlier were being openly discussed in student circles and popular science publications for the first time in a generation, and a wave of public curiosity about "flying saucers" (飞碟 — feidie) swept Chinese universities and popular science magazines, mirroring (with a roughly decade's lag) the UFO enthusiasm that had already crested in the United States and Western Europe.

That curiosity had an institutional home. On September 20, 1979, a "China UFO Enthusiasts' Liaison Office" was established at Wuhan University; by May 1980 it had become the China UFO Research Association (中国UFO研究会), which by the mid-1980s had more than forty branches and thousands of members (Malcolm Thompson, 2020). In December 1980 UPI reported that about 300 "UFO researchers" had formed China's first academic society on the subject, based in Wuhan and led by a 26-year-old astrophysics student; Kook Science's history of the association names its leader in 1980–83 as Zha (Cha) Leping. It was a group of Wuhan University students representing this association who, in 1981, met astronomer Liu Yan at the Purple Mountain Observatory in Nanjing and drew him into the case.

The association arrived in the middle of what UPI, in a Peking dispatch of December 4, 1980, called China's "UFO fever." The wire report, based on Xinhua, described about 300 members drawn from workers, students, teachers, journalists, doctors and researchers, with branches in Peking, Shanghai, Guangdong, Sichuan, Shanxi, Shaanxi, Hubei and Guangxi, and a journal, UFO Exploration (飞碟探索), reporting sightings at home and abroad. It noted an "outburst of UFO reports" in the Chinese press over the preceding months, including a photograph published by the Peking Evening News of an object seen by three campers near the Great Wall. When the spiral appeared eight months later, there was already a national network of enthusiasts ready to collect reports, and a popular press willing to print them, which helps explain how quickly the July 24 event produced some 70 articles and broadcasts.

The Purple Mountain Observatory (紫金山天文台, also transliterated Zijinshan Observatory), a Chinese Academy of Sciences institute on the mountain of the same name outside Nanjing, was a natural clearinghouse for a nationwide "strange lights in the sky" event: it had planetary astronomers, meteor and asteroid specialists, and solar-radio physicists able to calculate a moving light's altitude, speed and trajectory from scattered eyewitness reports of elevation angle and direction.

One of those astronomers, Wang Sichao, had already taken an interest in such reports. According to his obituary in The Paper, in September 1971 amateur astronomers in the Yangzhou area of Jiangsu and in Daxing near Beijing saw a "full-moon-sized spiral luminous object" in the northwestern sky one evening; Wang analyzed their reports and concluded the object was real, not an optical illusion or a known celestial phenomenon. (A 2010 profile dates his first contact with UFO reports to 1972, from a report in Gaoyou.) Chinese researchers logged similar spiral sightings through the 1970s; the 1982 Hangtian article says the Chinese UFO Research Association counted at least three such spirals over northwest China in the previous four years. Zhang Zhousheng of the Yunnan Astronomical Observatory in Kunming, an officer of the Kunming UFO Research Association, later wrote that in early June 1981 he had issued a forecast of the next appearance based on the pattern he had found, and that it was borne out on July 24. His paper does not reproduce the forecast, and this file has not found an independent copy of it.

Complete Timeline

DateEvent
September 1971Amateur astronomers near Yangzhou and in Daxing, Beijing, report a full-moon-sized spiral in the northwestern sky; Wang Sichao analyzes the reports, beginning his long interest in UFO cases.
September 20, 1979The "China UFO Enthusiasts' Liaison Office" is established at Wuhan University (Malcolm Thompson, Made in China Journal, 2020).
By May 1980The organization is renamed the Chinese UFO Research Association; by December UPI reports about 300 members.
Early June 1981By his own later account, Zhang Zhousheng of the Yunnan Astronomical Observatory issues a forecast that a spiral object will appear again; he writes that it was fulfilled on July 24.
July 24, 1981, ~22:33–22:38A bright, star-like point appears to the north (as seen from Sichuan and Yunnan, per Long Ruyi), brightens and oscillates. Later Chinese retrospectives date the first sighting to 22:33; Long Ruyi gives 22:38.
July 24, 1981, ~22:38–22:45A cloud-like band of light forms around the point and develops into a rotating spiral; retrospectives describe five or six rings of light, the outermost purple-red. About 300 people watching an open-air film in Xichang, Sichuan, see it.
July 24, 1981, ~22:45–22:52The object fades from view. Long Ruyi puts the whole appearance at six or seven minutes; Xinhua reported sightings of one to ten minutes between 22:30 and 23:30.
Late July–August 1981Newspapers report astronomers attributing the display to meteoroids from a Cassiopeia meteor shower (Sixth Tone, 2023).
1981–1982The Purple Mountain Observatory and the Sichuan UFO Research Association independently calculate an altitude of 500 km (±10%), a speed of several kilometers per second and a retrograde path inclined 112° (±5%, as printed) to the equator, which Long Ruyi says refuted the meteor theory.
Within several months of the eventApproximately 40 Chinese newspapers, periodicals, and radio stations publish or broadcast some 70 news reports and analytical articles; Xinhua transmits the story abroad and the Hong Kong press reports it (Long Ruyi).
1982Long Ruyi's article "First UFO Incident for Our Country" appears in Hangtian (Aerospace), no. 4, 1982, pp. 12–13, weighing a "meteor theory," an "aircraft theory" and a "flying saucer theory."
September 11, 1981UPI reports Xinhua's third story on the object: seen over Tibet, Peking and at least 12 other provinces "almost simultaneously," between 10:30 and 11:30 p.m., for one to ten minutes; Xinhua also suggested the same object was seen over San Diego that night.
September 1983The U.S. Air Force Foreign Technology Division issues an English translation of Long Ruyi's article as FTD-ID(RS)T-1019-83; the article notes that "the U.S. Center for UFO research in Illinois" was following the event.
1981 onwardLiu Yan publishes his analysis, his first UFO article, in Amateur Astronomer (天文爱好者): the phenomenon was most likely produced by an artificial spacecraft at about 650 km. He goes on to answer at least 2,000 letters from witnesses. Wang Sichao collects more than 70 reports on the case and studies it for over twenty years; Chinese retrospectives give his figures as 650 km altitude and 1.6 km/s.
June 17, 2016Wang Sichao dies in Nanjing, aged 77, after a cerebral hemorrhage. He had joined the Purple Mountain Observatory in 1963 and retired in 1999.

The Night of July 24, 1981

What separates the July 24, 1981 event from most UFO sightings is not its strangeness — Chinese observers had logged spiral and arc-shaped lights several times through the 1970s — but its geographic and demographic scale. The best contemporary English source is a translation, made by the U.S. Air Force's Foreign Technology Division in 1983, of an article by Long Ruyi in the Chinese magazine Hangtian (no. 4, 1982). Long writes that on a clear, starlit, moonless night over southwest and northwest China and much of southern and south-central China, "at 2238 hours, a strange star-shaped bright spot was sighted by a large number of people in Sichuan and Yunnan provinces when it appeared in the sky to the north," and that "in the brief six or seven minutes from its appearance to its disappearance, some 10,000,000 people" saw it. That figure is Long's claim, not a count. Later Chinese retrospectives give "more than a million" witnesses and times of 22:33 to 22:52, and Xinhua, as reported by UPI on September 11, 1981, said most witnesses saw it between 10:30 and 11:30 p.m. for one to ten minutes.

Long Ruyi's account describes the sequence: the star-like point grew brighter, began to oscillate, and then "a cloud-like band of light formed around the circumference of the bright spot," producing a "huge spiral shaped UFO with its bright silver color." Chinese retrospectives add that the tail had five or six rings of light, the outermost glowing purple-red, around a yellowish central body, and that the spiral rotated while moving slowly from east to west. In Guizhou, according to Xinhua via UPI, peasants saw a "star" that grew a tail and then took the shape of a coiling "dragon." Long also reports that some witnesses said the object stopped and hovered for several minutes, changed direction, or showed a bell-shaped center with a row of portholes; he notes that such reports cannot be dismissed outright but that proof of an alien source "is apparently lacking." Estimates of its apparent size vary between accounts; Zhang Zhousheng's general description of such spirals compares them to a huge coiled mosquito-repellent incense spiral.

The display was seen at about the same time from places hundreds of kilometers apart, which rules out a local, low-altitude source such as a searchlight, a balloon or a nearby aircraft's lights. Both the conventional and the exotic interpretations agree that the source was very high, hundreds of kilometers up.

Geographic Scope

Exactly which provinces saw the display, and how many, varies by source. Long Ruyi's article names only Sichuan and Yunnan, within a clear-sky region covering southwest and northwest China and much of southern and south-central China. Xinhua, as reported by UPI, said the object first reported over Tibet was also seen in Peking and at least twelve other provinces. Chinese-language retrospectives list Tibet, Sichuan, Qinghai, Gansu, Guizhou, Hubei, Henan, Guangxi, Yunnan, Shaanxi and Shanxi; Wang Sichao spoke of fifteen provinces and cities; Zhang Zhousheng wrote of more than twenty provinces, cities and autonomous regions. The popular "fourteen provinces" figure is roughly consistent with the Xinhua count. All of these describe a corridor from China's northwest to its south-central provinces, consistent with an object at very high altitude.

Specific, named-location testimony survives from within that corridor. In Xichang, a city in southern Sichuan's Liangshan region (and the site of a satellite launch center that became operational in 1984), about 300 people watching an open-air film saw the object, according to a Chinese retrospective. The Purple Mountain Observatory in Nanjing, far to the east in Jiangsu, became the center of the analysis because it collected reports from across the country; this file has not found a source saying its own staff saw the object.

The Scientific Response

Long Ruyi's 1982 article sorted the explanations into three: a "meteor theory," an "aircraft theory" (spacecraft or spy plane) and a "flying saucer theory." The case's later history is largely an argument between the second and the third.

The first explanation to reach print was a meteor theory. Sixth Tone's 2023 profile of Liu Yan says newspapers at the time reported astronomers attributing the display to meteoroids from a Cassiopeia meteor shower, though many experts disagreed. Long Ruyi describes the meteor theory as positing a body travelling "at a speed of 12km/second and at an altitude of 5000km, headed toward the sun." He then reports that the Purple Mountain Observatory and the Sichuan UFO Research Association, working independently from witnesses' elevation angles and apparent angular speeds at different locations, both found "the altitude of the UFO which appeared on 24 Jul 1981 was 500km (±10%), its speed was several kilometers per second and it traveled along a reverse orbit which had an included angle of 112° (±5%) with the equator," and concludes: "The various data of the 'meteor theory' have been refuted by the facts." An ordinary meteor burns up in seconds roughly 75 to 120 km up; an object visible for several minutes at about 500 km does not fit.

The second, longer-lived explanation credited the object to human technology. A rocket stage or spacecraft venting residual propellant at high altitude produces an expanding, sunlit gas cloud that, seen from the dark ground, can appear as a bright, rotating spiral. This is the mechanism confirmed for the 2009 "Norwegian spiral," produced by a failed Russian Bulava submarine-launched missile test and tied to that launch within a day. Liu Yan, drawn into the case in 1981 when his colleague Wang Sichao brought him to meet a group of Wuhan University students from the Chinese UFO Research Association, published his analysis, his first UFO article, in Amateur Astronomer. According to the 2023 Jiefang Daily profile (reprinted by Sina), he concluded that the phenomenon was "very likely produced by an artificial spacecraft in space, at an altitude of about 650 kilometers." The same profile describes a 2011 analysis that attributed it to "the residual trail formed when a jettisoned final rocket stage released its remaining fuel." Long Ruyi himself, writing in 1982, leaned toward a spy-craft explanation and ended by saying the incident "still waits for those who know the inside story to come forward."

The difficulty is that the specific launch such an explanation requires has never been identified. Chinese retrospectives say a third-stage booster was "largely ruled out" and that no matching booster data has been found. Jonathan McDowell's public launch catalogue (GCAT) lists no orbital launch anywhere in the world on July 22–25, 1981. The nearest Soviet orbital launches were Kosmos 1283 (Soyuz-U, July 17) and Kosmos 1284 (Soyuz-U, July 29), with a Proton launch on July 30; the catalogue also lists Soviet ICBM test flights on July 18, 19, 23 and 28. China made no orbital launch in 1981 before the Feng Bao-1 flight that carried three Shijian-2 satellites on September 20 (Beijing time), the country's first multi-payload launch. The rocket-venting mechanism remains the most plausible general category of explanation for a spiral of this kind, but the specific, dated launch that would close the case has never surfaced.

The Hangtian Article as a Source

Because so much of the English-language literature on this case traces back to a single translated document, it is worth being clear about what that document is. Long Ruyi's article ran in Hangtian (航天, "Aerospace"), a Chinese popular aerospace magazine, in its fourth issue of 1982, a year after the event. The FTD translation is three pages long, and two passages are marked "(portion of text omitted)," so the English version is incomplete. It is a magazine survey of opinions rather than a technical report: it summarizes the press coverage, reports the Purple Mountain Observatory and Sichuan calculations in one paragraph, and gives space to witness claims of hovering, sudden turns and portholes before concluding that proof of an alien source "is apparently lacking." It also observes that researchers abroad had no photographs of any craft "with a very distinct spiral trail." Much later English retelling, including the "U.S. Air Force suggested a spy plane" line repeated by some magazines, comes from misreading this translation as an American assessment. Read as what it is, the document is a useful contemporary Chinese source for the time, the sky conditions, the scale of the coverage and the early calculations, and an unreliable one for the number of witnesses.

What the Launch Record Shows

Because the rocket-venting explanation depends on a launch, the public launch record is the obvious place to test it. Jonathan McDowell's General Catalog of Artificial Space Objects (GCAT), the most complete public list of launches, shows a busy but not unusual month. Soviet Soyuz-U rockets carried Kosmos 1279 (July 1), Kosmos 1280 (July 2), Kosmos 1281 (July 7), Kosmos 1282 (July 15), Kosmos 1283 (July 17) and Kosmos 1284 (July 29) into orbit; a Vostok rocket launched the Meteor-Priroda weather satellite on July 10; and a Proton launched the Raduga communications satellite on July 30. None of these falls on July 24. The catalogue also lists Soviet ICBM test flights, which climb to about 1,000 km on suborbital paths: an R-36MU on July 18, a UR-100NU on July 19, an MR-UR-100 on July 23 (no time of day recorded), a UR-100NU on July 28, and an RT-2P on July 29. A missile test of this kind is the type of event that produced the 2009 Norwegian spiral, but none is listed for July 24 itself, and the catalogue does not give a flight path that could be compared with the Chinese calculations. On the American side, the catalogue lists only sounding rockets and meteorological rockets for July 24, at ranges far from China.

China itself made no orbital launch in 1981 until the Feng Bao-1 flight of September 20 (Beijing time) that put three Shijian-2 satellites into orbit, the country's first multi-payload launch. A Chinese launch is therefore not a candidate either. The gap matters: the Norwegian case was closed because Russia's Defense Ministry acknowledged a failed Bulava test the next day, and no comparable admission exists for July 24, 1981. Long Ruyi's closing remark, that the incident "still waits for those who know the inside story to come forward," is still true more than forty years later.

Could the Object Have Been Sunlit?

A venting cloud is only visible at night if it is high enough to catch sunlight that has already left the ground. JPL Horizons puts the Sun about 28° below the horizon, toward the northwest, at 22:40 Beijing time as seen from Chengdu, and about 31° below as seen from Kunming. The sky was therefore fully dark at ground level, as Long Ruyi says, while material several hundred kilometers up, toward the north and northwest where the Sun lay below the horizon, could still be in sunlight. Long's account has the bright point first appearing "in the sky to the north" as seen from Sichuan and Yunnan. That is consistent with a sunlit cloud at the altitudes the Chinese calculations give, though it does not identify the source.

International Attention

The scale of the sighting guaranteed it would not stay a purely domestic story. According to Long Ruyi, within the first few months about 40 Chinese newspapers, periodicals and radio stations published or broadcast some 70 news reports and analytical articles, Xinhua transmitted the story worldwide, and the Hong Kong press kept reporting it "with impressive layouts." On September 11, 1981, UPI moved an English-language story from Peking describing Xinhua's third report on the object.

American attention came through the U.S. Air Force's Foreign Technology Division (FTD) at Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, which translated Long Ruyi's Hangtian article ("First UFO Incident for Our Country," translated by Randy Dorsey) and released it as FTD-ID(RS)T-1019-83 in September 1983. The FTD added no analysis of its own; the opinions in the document, including the spy-plane suggestion, are Long's. The article records that "the U.S. Center for UFO research in Illinois has also followed this event with great interest," most likely a reference to J. Allen Hynek's Center for UFO Studies (CUFOS).

The Xinhua report carried by UPI added one claim that does not survive scrutiny: that the same object had been seen over San Diego, California, the same night. At 22:38 Beijing time it was 07:38 on the morning of July 24 in San Diego (Pacific Daylight Time), so an evening sighting there would have come more than half a day later. No San Diego report has been located for this file.

Key Witnesses

Liu Yan

Solar Radio Astronomer, Purple Mountain Observatory — Principal "Rocket Venting" Analyst

Born in Haimen, Jiangsu province (he turned 80 in 2023), Liu moved to Shanghai as a child, entered Nanjing University's astronomy department in 1960, and joined the Purple Mountain Observatory as a specialist in solar radio emissions. He was drawn into UFO research in 1981, when colleague Wang Sichao took him to meet a group of Wuhan University students representing the Chinese UFO Research Association. His analysis of the July 24 event, his first UFO article, appeared in Amateur Astronomer and concluded that the phenomenon was most likely produced by an artificial spacecraft at about 650 km. Over the following four decades he estimates he wrote at least 2,000 replies to letters from witnesses; in one, about a "bright star" that seemed to explode near the northern horizon at about 10 p.m. on June 18, 1982, he explained it as a spacecraft more than 1,000 km up and wrote that "this could not possibly be a 'flying saucer' from aliens." He also examined the 1994 claim of forestry worker Meng Zhaoguo, who said he had been abducted at Phoenix Mountain in Heilongjiang. In 1988 the Chinese UFO Research Association became a branch society of the qigong science research association, and some of its later meetings included qigong and psychic performances, a development Liu's profiles describe him as distancing himself from.

Wang Sichao

Planetary Astronomer & Meteoriticist, Purple Mountain Observatory — Lead Institutional Investigator

Born in 1937 in Chaoan, Guangdong province, Wang graduated in astrophysics from Peking University's geophysics department in 1963 and joined the Purple Mountain Observatory that year, working on planetary astronomy until he retired in 1999. His interest in UFOs began in the early 1970s: his obituary dates it to his analysis of reports of a full-moon-sized spiral seen in September 1971 by amateur astronomers near Yangzhou and in Daxing, while a 2010 profile dates his first case to a 1972 report from Gaoyou. In 1981 he introduced the visiting Wuhan University students to his colleague Liu Yan. Wang pursued his own longer study of the July 24 case, collecting more than 70 eyewitness reports and studying it for more than twenty years; Chinese retrospectives give his results as an altitude of 650 km and a speed of 1.6 km/s. He called it possibly the most widely witnessed UFO event in the world. In a 2010 interview he said he was convinced extraterrestrials exist, that about 20 percent of the thousands of Chinese cases he had studied could basically exclude human causes, and that seven or eight high-quality reports were very probably alien craft; the same profile credits him with the first quantitative scientific analysis of UFOs, presented at a world UFO congress. He took part in the first World UFO Congress in Dalian in 2005. Wang died in Nanjing on June 17, 2016, aged 77, following a cerebral hemorrhage.

Zhang Zhousheng

Researcher, Yunnan Astronomical Observatory; Officer, Kunming UFO Research Association

A researcher at the Yunnan Astronomical Observatory in Kunming and an officer of the Kunming UFO Research Association (vice-chairman in the byline of his paper; chairman in the blog that reproduces it), Zhang studied China's recurring spiral and "spring-shaped" luminous sightings in a paper titled "A Novel Astronomical Phenomenon — Spiral-Shaped Flying Objects." He describes such objects as appearing several hundred to nearly a thousand kilometers up, says astronomical bodies had received thousands of reports of the phenomenon (and more than a thousand for the July 24, 1981 event alone), and puts the 1981 event at about 22:40 Beijing time, seen by "millions" in more than twenty provinces, cities and autonomous regions. He also writes that in early June 1981 he had forecast the object's appearance from the regularities he had found, and that the forecast was fulfilled. The forecast itself is not reproduced in the paper, and this file has not found an independent copy, so its exact wording and date window cannot be checked.

The General Public Across Western and Southern China

Collective Testimony — Civilians, Meteorologists & Astronomers

The overwhelming majority of this case's witnesses were, and remain, anonymous: residents of cities and rural counties across western, southwestern and south-central China whose names were never individually recorded in the surviving literature. This case file does not invent named individuals where none are documented. The one specific, named-location group in the sources is the crowd of about 300 people watching an open-air film in Xichang, Sichuan. Wang Sichao collected more than 70 written reports and Zhang Zhousheng more than a thousand, but the individual reports have not been published.

The Five Observables Assessment

🔽
Anti-Gravity Lift
N/A
⚡
Instant Accel.
N/A
💨
Hypersonic
Absent
👁️
Low Observability
Speculative
🌊
Trans-Medium
N/A

Assessment: Measured against the modern Five Observables framework, this case is a poor fit for a genuine anomalous-craft reading. The institutional calculations reported by Long Ruyi describe an object moving at several kilometers per second, and the figures attributed to Wang Sichao (1.6 km/s), well below orbital velocity, on a steady path over several minutes: the signature of ballistic debris or an expanding gas cloud, not of a maneuvering craft. Some witnesses, per Long Ruyi, said it hovered and changed direction, but those reports are not reflected in any trajectory calculation. No radar data exists for this case at all, so "low observability" can only be scored speculative. Trans-medium travel and anti-gravity lift are not applicable.

Evidence Assessment

Supporting Anomalous Origin

  • Wang Sichao, a career Chinese Academy of Sciences planetary astronomer, studied the case for more than twenty years, collected more than 70 reports, and remained convinced that extraterrestrials exist
  • Despite exhaustive searching by multiple independent Chinese researchers over more than four decades, no specific rocket, missile, or satellite launch record has ever been publicly matched to the object's calculated date, altitude, and trajectory
  • The object was seen simultaneously across a very wide region of China, from places hundreds of kilometers apart
  • Zhang Zhousheng wrote that he had forecast the appearance in early June 1981 (the forecast itself has not been found)
  • The Purple Mountain Observatory and Sichuan calculations placed the object on a retrograde path inclined about 112° to the equator, and no launch on that track has been identified

Supporting Conventional Explanation

  • The object's visual signature — a slowly expanding, rotating spiral of light on a steady trajectory — closely resembles the confirmed 2009 Norwegian spiral, a documented rocket-venting event
  • Liu Yan, an equally credentialed Purple Mountain Observatory astronomer, concluded it was most likely produced by an artificial spacecraft at about 650 km
  • Every published trajectory calculation found a speed far below Earth orbital velocity and a steady path, the signature of an unpowered object or gas cloud
  • No radar data, physical trace evidence, or verified photograph of the object survives for independent analysis today
  • The meteor theory's rapid rise and collapse shows that early public explanations of this event were not reliable, cutting against overconfidence in any single reading, mundane or otherwise
  • The public launch record for July 1981 does not rule out a rocket-body or missile origin in general — it simply fails to identify a specific vehicle, which is a gap in the documentary record rather than positive evidence against the mechanism

Why "Disputed"

The 1981 Chinese Spiral Mass Sighting earns a DISPUTED classification because its two principal Chinese investigators, both astronomers at the same Chinese Academy of Sciences institute, reached different conclusions. Liu Yan concluded that the phenomenon was most likely produced by an artificial spacecraft, the kind of explanation later confirmed for Norway's 2009 sky spiral. Wang Sichao studied the case far longer, said he was convinced extraterrestrials exist, and did not accept a conventional resolution; Chinese retrospectives built on his figures conclude it may have been a special spacecraft linked to extraterrestrial intelligence.

What is not disputed: a real, widely witnessed high-altitude phenomenon occurred over a large part of China on the night of July 24, 1981; the early meteor explanation was tested against trajectory data and found not to fit; and the conventional explanation favored by the balance of the evidence — a human-made object venting propellant at high altitude — has never been matched to a specific, dated launch. The mechanism is very probably mundane, but this case file cannot point to the actual rocket.

Sensor & Instrumentation Detection Profile

No radar, infrared, or other instrumented sensor record of the object is known to exist. The Purple Mountain Observatory and the Sichuan UFO Research Association reconstructed the object's altitude, speed and trajectory from witnesses' reported elevation angles and apparent angular speeds at different locations. Long Ruyi mentions "a few blurred photos," but none has surfaced in a verifiable, rights-clear form.

Environmental & Geospatial Context

Long Ruyi describes "a clear, brightly starlit night" with the Milky Way visible and no moon over southwest and northwest China and much of southern and south-central China. JPL Horizons confirms that the Moon (about 47% lit, waning) had not yet risen at 22:38 Beijing time as seen from Chengdu; it rose at about 01:00. The affected region spans the Tibetan Plateau, the arid northwest, the Sichuan Basin and the lower provinces of south-central China, a spread consistent with an object at very substantial altitude rather than a local phenomenon.

Observer Credibility & Occupational Profile

This case's credibility rests less on any individual witness than on the number of independent, simultaneous observers across a very wide area. The names of individual witnesses do not survive in the accessible literature. The case's two principal analysts, Liu Yan and Wang Sichao, were career Chinese Academy of Sciences astronomers who published under their own names; Liu's analysis appeared in Amateur Astronomer.

Physical & Material Assays

No physical trace evidence of any kind — debris, soil disturbance, radiation readings, or recovered material — is associated with this case; the phenomenon was, by every account, purely visual and left nothing behind at ground level for later collection or testing. No fragment, sample, or artifact connected to the event has ever been produced for scientific analysis by any party, proponent or skeptic.

Historical Precedents & Archive Matches

Spiral-shaped luminous objects are a recurring category in the Chinese UFO literature, and this case sits within a documented pattern rather than standing alone. Zhang Zhousheng's paper describes the type, and the 1971 spiral analyzed by Wang Sichao is an earlier example. Internationally, a close analog is the Petrozavodsk Phenomenon of September 20, 1977, a radiating light display over the Soviet city of Petrozavodsk widely attributed to a Soviet satellite launch from the Plesetsk Cosmodrome. The most important comparison case postdates this one by nearly three decades: the December 9, 2009 "Norwegian spiral" over northern Norway, in which a failed Russian Bulava missile test from a submarine in the White Sea vented propellant in a rotating spiral visually much like the Chinese descriptions, and which was publicly tied to its launch within a day, something this 1981 case has never achieved. The Kapustin Yar UAP Sighting, centered on a Soviet missile-testing range, offers a further comparison for how rocket activity in this era generated sightings later traced to launches or tests.

Material Analysis

Because this case left no physical trace evidence at ground level, "material analysis" here properly concerns the case's photographic and documentary record rather than any recovered object or sample.

The Missing Photographs

Long Ruyi's 1982 article mentions "a few blurred photos" taken of the July 24, 1981 object and says there was no other physical evidence "nor any good record of a signal." None of these images is known to survive today in any publicly accessible, verifiable, rights-clear form; this case file was unable to locate an original print, negative, or period newspaper reproduction of any of them.

The Documentary Record

What does survive is the documentary record: the roughly 70 news reports and articles Long Ruyi counted in the first months, Long's own article and its 1983 FTD translation, UPI's report of the Xinhua coverage, and the trajectory results reported for the Purple Mountain Observatory and the Sichuan UFO Research Association, Liu Yan and Wang Sichao. This paper trail, rather than any physical artifact, is the evidentiary core of the case.

Supporting Non-Terrestrial or Anomalous Origin

  • Wang Sichao's decades-long study led him, and Chinese retrospectives using his figures, to doubt a conventional explanation
  • Some witnesses quoted by Long Ruyi said the object hovered and changed direction, which venting debris would not do (though no calculation reflects this)
  • No specific matching launch record has been identified despite extensive searching, leaving the conventional explanation formally unconfirmed rather than proven

Supporting Terrestrial/Conventional Origin

  • The object's visual signature closely resembles the confirmed 2009 Norwegian spiral, a documented and photographically well-recorded rocket-venting event
  • Every published speed calculation found the object moving far below Earth orbital velocity on a steady path — the signature of an unpowered object, not powered flight
  • The lack of any surviving photograph or physical trace makes independent re-analysis of the raw data impossible, and the case rests entirely on secondhand eyewitness testimony filtered through 1980s-era Chinese science journalism
  • A near-identical general phenomenon (rocket/satellite propellant venting) is independently well documented at multiple other sites and eras, including Petrozavodsk, giving the conventional hypothesis a strong prior even without a matched launch record for this specific date
⚠  FORENSIC DATA PROFILE Schema v1.0 — Six-Domain Classification
01 Spatiotemporal Metrics Where & When
Precise Timestamp
July 24, 1981, about 22:38 Beijing Time (UTC+8) per Long Ruyi (1982); later retrospectives give 22:33–22:52
Duration
Six or seven minutes (Long Ruyi, 1982); later retrospectives give about 19 minutes (22:33–22:52); Xinhua reported one to ten minutes
Geographic Coordinates
No single fixed location — a moving aerial phenomenon observed across a corridor from roughly 25–40°N, 90–120°E; analysis centered on the Purple Mountain Observatory, Nanjing (32.07°N, 118.83°E)
Location Typology
Large-scale sky event over western, southwestern and south-central China; Xinhua cited Tibet, Beijing and at least 12 other provinces
Sun / Moon Position
Nighttime; clear, cloudless sky reported across the affected region
02 Observational Metrics The Five Observables (AATIP)
Anti-Gravity Lift
N/A — no evidence of powered or lift-generating flight; motion consistent with ballistic/orbital debris
Sudden Acceleration
Absent — all institutional calculations found a stable, unaccelerated trajectory throughout the 20-minute observation window
Hypersonic Velocity
Absent — calculated speed of several km/s, well below the ~7.9 km/s low-Earth-orbit velocity Wang Sichao explicitly measured it against
Low Observability
Speculative — no radar data exists to assess radar cross-section or detectability
Trans-Medium Travel
N/A — no accounts describe surface or subsurface transition
03 Physical & Morphological Metrics Appearance
Primary Shape
Rotating spiral with five or six distinct luminous rings; began as a single bright point before developing a circumferential band
Luminosity & Color
Bright silvery-white overall, with the outermost ring described as violet-red; apparent brightness comparable to a first-magnitude star at onset
Apparent Size
Not consistently reported; described as a huge spiral with five or six rings
Estimated Altitude
About 500 km (±10%) per the Purple Mountain Observatory and Sichuan UFO Research Association calculations reported by Long Ruyi (1982); about 650 km per Liu Yan and per the figures attributed to Wang Sichao. Zhang Zhousheng puts spirals of this type at several hundred to nearly 1,000 km.
Acoustics
No sound reported by any witness account reviewed for this case file, consistent with an object at extreme altitude
04 Environmental & Contextual Metrics The Surroundings
Atmospheric Conditions
Clear, cloudless night sky reported consistently across the affected corridor, maximizing visibility over an unusually wide geographic area
Radar Telemetry
None known to exist or to have been released; China's civilian and military radar records from this period are not publicly accessible
Air Traffic Logs
Not available; no contemporaneous civil or military aviation logs relevant to this event have surfaced in the public record
Space Triggers
No orbital launch anywhere on July 22–25, 1981 (McDowell GCAT). Nearest Soviet orbital launches: Kosmos 1283 (July 17) and Kosmos 1284 (July 29), Proton/Raduga (July 30); Soviet ICBM test flights on July 18, 19, 23 and 28. China's next launch was Feng Bao-1/Shijian-2 on September 20, 1981.
Lunar Illumination
About 47% lit (waning); below the horizon at 22:38 Beijing time from Chengdu, rising at about 01:00 (JPL Horizons), consistent with Long Ruyi's "no moon"
Historical Weather
Clear, starlit and moonless over the sighting region (Long Ruyi, 1982)
05 Forensic & Material Evidence Metrics Hard Proof
Multi-Spectrum Imagery
A small number of contemporaneous photographs are described in secondary sources as taken but blurred; none is known to survive today in a publicly accessible, verifiable, rights-clear form
Electromagnetic Anomalies
None reported in any source reviewed for this case file
Physical Trace Data
None — no debris, sample, or ground trace of any kind is associated with this event
Biological Impact
None reported
06 Witness & Data Credibility Metrics The Human Element
Observer Profile
Unknown numbers of civilians across western and southern China (claims range from over a million to 10 million); analysts Liu Yan and Wang Sichao, Chinese Academy of Sciences astronomers
Sensory Type
Mass, geographically independent, simultaneous unaided-eye visual observation; no instrumented sensor corroboration
Record Quality Score
46/100Moderate: exceptionally broad, independently corroborated witness base including trained professional observers, and two credentialed institutional trajectory analyses. Reduced by: total absence of surviving physical evidence or verifiable photography, no radar corroboration, and an unresolved 40-plus-year gap between the favored conventional mechanism and any actual matching launch record.Rates how complete and reliable the record is. The credibility score at the top of the page is a separate judgment.
Investigation Status
Unresolved

The Conventional Explanation Candidate

Four explanations have been proposed for the July 24, 1981 spiral. One (the meteor theory) is effectively refuted; the balance of the evidence favors rocket or spacecraft venting without being able to close the case.

Rocket or Spacecraft Fuel Venting (The Liu Yan Hypothesis)

Liu Yan's 1981 conclusion, that the phenomenon was most likely produced by an artificial spacecraft at about 650 km, remains this case's strongest general explanation. Spent rocket stages and missiles at high altitude sometimes vent residual propellant; the escaping propellant forms an expanding cloud of ice crystals and gas that, lit by sunlight still reaching that altitude after ground sunset, can appear from below as a bright, rotating spiral as the tumbling parent body winds the venting gas into a spiral. This mechanism was confirmed for the 2009 Norwegian spiral, tied within a day to a failed Bulava missile test. Its weakness is evidentiary rather than mechanistic: no specific launch has been matched to this event's date and calculated track. McDowell's launch catalogue shows no orbital launch on July 22–25, 1981 (see the Forensic Data Profile).

Cassiopeiad/Perseid Meteor Shower Theory

The first explanation to reach print, reported in newspapers within days, attributed the display to meteoroids from a Cassiopeia meteor shower. It was tested rather than merely dismissed: the Purple Mountain Observatory and the Sichuan UFO Research Association independently calculated an altitude of about 500 km and a speed of several kilometers per second, and Long Ruyi wrote that "the various data of the 'meteor theory' have been refuted by the facts." A meteor burns up in seconds at 75–120 km altitude; an object visible for minutes at 500 km does not fit.

Spy Plane or Spy Satellite (The Long Ruyi Hypothesis)

An earlier version of this page said the U.S. Air Force's Foreign Technology Division "floated" a malfunctioning American reconnaissance aircraft. That is a misreading: the FTD document is a translation of Long Ruyi's Chinese article, and the suggestion is Long's. Under a heading translated as "Spy satellite is doubtful," he notes that aircraft and spacecraft "have always been a major source of UFOs" and that, according to U.S. sources, counterintelligence organizations believed UFOs over space centers and missile sites were spy planes; after weighing the "flying saucer" reports, he writes that the lack of proof "causes us to return to the spy plane hypothesis." No specific aircraft, mission or satellite has ever been identified, and no known aircraft would produce a rotating spiral seen across much of China at an altitude of hundreds of kilometers.

Extraterrestrial Craft (Chinese Retrospectives Using Wang Sichao’s Figures)

Wang Sichao carried real institutional weight: a career Chinese Academy of Sciences planetary astronomer who collected more than 70 reports on this case and studied it for more than twenty years. He said publicly that he was convinced extraterrestrials exist, that about 20 percent of the thousands of Chinese cases he studied could basically exclude human causes, and that seven or eight high-quality reports were very probably alien craft. Chinese retrospectives that use his figures (650 km, 1.6 km/s, an 11-second rotation) conclude that the July 24 object may have been a special spacecraft linked to extraterrestrial intelligence. This file has not found a statement in which Wang himself gives a final verdict on this case. The view has not gained general acceptance: his colleague Liu Yan reached a conventional conclusion, and a slow, steady object far below orbital speed is what venting debris would look like.

The Assessment

Rocket/Spacecraft Fuel Venting

Highly Plausible Mechanism, Unconfirmed Attribution

The mechanism itself is proven — visually near-identical to the confirmed 2009 Norway spiral — and matches this case's own data closely. But no specific launch has ever been matched to it after more than 40 years of searching, so this case file rates it plausible in category while inconclusive in specific attribution.

Cassiopeiad/Perseid Meteor Shower

Implausible

Directly refuted by the Purple Mountain Observatory's and Sichuan UFO Research Association's own trajectory calculations, which found an altitude of about 500 km and a speed of several kilometers per second, incompatible with a meteor's brief atmospheric transit.

Spy Plane or Spy Satellite

Implausible

Suggested by Long Ruyi in 1982 (not by the U.S. Air Force, which only translated his article). No supporting aircraft, mission or satellite has been identified, and no aircraft could produce a spiral seen across much of China from hundreds of kilometers up.

Extraterrestrial Craft

Inconclusive

The view of Chinese retrospectives built on Wang Sichao's figures. It does not explain why such a craft would move like slow, unpowered debris.

Related Cases

📄  DECLASSIFIED GOVERNMENT RECORDS Primary source documents from U.S. and allied government archives

Confirmed Documents & Official Records

U.S. Air Force / DIA Foreign Technology Division Translated Technical Report 1982–1983
FTD-ID(RS)T-1019-83 — Long Ruyi, “First UFO Incident for Our Country” (translation) →

The Foreign Technology Division's September 1983 English translation (by Randy Dorsey; DTIC ADA133326) of Long Ruyi's article in Hangtian, no. 4, 1982, pp. 12–13. The three-page article gives 22:38, six or seven minutes, "some 10,000,000" witnesses, the Purple Mountain Observatory and Sichuan calculations, and Long's spy-plane suggestion. PDF hosted by The Black Vault.

UNCLASSIFIED (declassified)
United Press International Wire Service Report September 11, 1981
UPI Archives — September 11, 1981 →

UPI's archive for September 11, 1981, the date its Peking wire story reported Xinhua's third account of the July 24 object.

PUBLIC WIRE SERVICE RECORD

Further Reading — Recommended Literature

📖

The Soviet Space Race with Apollo

Asif A. Siddiqi

A definitive, Russian-source-based history of the Soviet space program's 1957–1975 era, providing the launch-manifest and rocket-family background necessary to evaluate — and, in this case, to rule out — specific Soviet launch candidates for July 1981.

DISCLOSURE: Some links above are affiliate links. If you purchase through them, OverClassified receives a small commission at no additional cost to you. This helps support independent research.

Essential Viewing

No Videos Available

A genuine search effort did not turn up a video dedicated specifically and primarily to the July 24, 1981 event, as opposed to generic "UFOs over China" compilations, unrelated modern Chinese sightings, or coverage of the visually similar but separate 2009 Norwegian spiral. Per this site's editorial policy, no off-topic or recycled video has been substituted.

Sources

  • Long Ruyi, "First UFO Incident for Our Country," Hangtian, no. 4, 1982, pp. 12–13; English translation by Randy Dorsey, Foreign Technology Division, Wright-Patterson AFB, FTD-ID(RS)T-1019-83, September 1983 (DTIC ADA133326). theblackvault.com (PDF)
  • Paul Loong, United Press International, "Chinese discovering UFOs," Peking, December 4, 1980. upi.com
  • NASA JPL Horizons, Moon and Sun positions from Chengdu and Kunming, July 24, 1981, 14:30–18:30 UT. ssd.jpl.nasa.gov
  • United Press International. "The official Chinese news agency said today an unidentified…", wire report, September 11, 1981. upi.com
  • Chen Shuyi (Shanghai Observer), "The Astronomer Who Calmed China's UFO Craze," profile of Liu Yan, trans. David Ball. Sixth Tone, May 20, 2023. sixthtone.com
  • "给UFO目击者写回信的人" ("The Man Who Wrote Back to UFO Witnesses"), profile of Liu Yan. Jiefang Daily. jfdaily.com
  • "给UFO目击者写回信的人|刘炎," reprint of Liu Yan profile. Sina Finance. finance.sina.cn
  • "This Day in History: China's Otherworldly 'Alien Sky Spiral' of 1981." That's Magazines (Beijing). thatsmags.com
  • "UFOs over China's Sichuan Province… and other mysteries." Open Minds TV. openminds.tv
  • "UFO Disclosure Chinese Style, 10-Million Witness Event," a reproduction of the FTD translation. Before It's News. beforeitsnews.com
  • "SPIRAL UFO REPORT," scanned translation excerpt of the 1981 technical analysis. SlideShare. slideshare.net
  • "天文学家王思潮:39年追踪UFO 坚信外星人的存在" ("Astronomer Wang Sichao: 39 Years Tracking UFOs, Convinced of Extraterrestrials"), biographical profile. China News Service. chinanews.com
  • "中科院紫金山天文台研究员、UFO研究专家王思潮逝世" ("CAS Purple Mountain Observatory Researcher and UFO Expert Wang Sichao Passes Away"), obituary. The Paper. thepaper.cn
  • Malcolm Thompson, "On UFOlogy with Chinese Characteristics and the Fate of Chinese Socialism," Made in China Journal, October 19, 2020. madeinchinajournal.com
  • 王思潮 (Wang Sichao), biographical entry. Chinese Wikipedia. zh.wikipedia.org
  • "一种新奇的天文现象——螺旋状飞行物" ("A Novel Astronomical Phenomenon — Spiral-Shaped Flying Objects"), Zhang Zhousheng's research paper, reproduced. Sina Blog. blog.sina.com.cn
  • "万年前洞穴符号与螺旋状UFO," Wang Sichao's own writing on spiral UFO phenomena. Sina Blog. blog.sina.com.cn
  • "一月八起UFO事件 专家预言明后年还有重大出现," discussion of the July 24, 1981 event among other Chinese UFO cases. China News Service. chinanews.com.cn
  • 中国UFO研究会 (Chinese UFO Research Association), organizational history entry. Baidu Baike. baike.baidu.com
  • "世界史上最大宗的UFO目击事件," retrospective on the July 24, 1981 sighting. Sina News. k.sina.com.cn
  • "我国最大的UFO事件," retrospective on the July 24, 1981 sighting. Ifeng (Phoenix New Media). innovation.ifeng.com
  • "中国最大的UFO事件:1981年轰动半个中国的螺旋UFO,目击证人超百万." UFO中文网. ufo86.com
  • "横跨中国十省的重大UFO事件." Qinghai News Network. qhnews.com
  • Jonathan McDowell, General Catalog of Artificial Space Objects (GCAT), launch list, July–September 1981. planet4589.org
  • "2009 Norwegian spiral anomaly," background on the confirmed rocket-venting comparison case. Wikipedia. en.wikipedia.org
  • Purple Mountain Observatory, institutional background. Wikipedia. en.wikipedia.org
  • Yunnan Astronomical Observatory, institutional background. Wikipedia. en.wikipedia.org

Corrections (October 2026)

A reading of the Foreign Technology Division document itself (FTD-ID(RS)T-1019-83, DTIC ADA133326) showed that much of what this page attributed to it was wrong. The document is a translation of Long Ruyi's article "First UFO Incident for Our Country" in Hangtian, no. 4, 1982. It does not mention "hundreds of thousands of onlookers," a 22:33–22:53 window or twenty minutes of visibility, or a list of Beijing and thirteen provinces; it gives 22:38, six or seven minutes, "some 10,000,000" witnesses, and names Sichuan and Yunnan. The "malfunctioning American reconnaissance aircraft" hypothesis was not the U.S. Air Force's; it is Long's spy-plane suggestion, which the FTD only translated. The 22:33–22:52 times and the Xichang film crowd come from later Chinese retrospectives, and the province count from Xinhua via UPI.

Following this review, the rating was changed from Disputed 34 to Disputed 32 (October 28, 2026), because the higher rating had rested partly on claims corrected or removed above.

Other fixes: Wang Sichao did not personally see the 1971 spiral; he analyzed reports from amateur astronomers near Yangzhou and in Daxing. No statement was found in which Wang gives a final "intelligent design" verdict on this case; the page now reports what he said in 2010 and what Chinese retrospectives conclude from his figures. Liu Yan's Amateur Astronomer conclusion was "an artificial spacecraft" at about 650 km; the "leftover fuel released by jettisoned rockets" wording belongs to a 2011 analysis, and his "could not possibly be a flying saucer" remark comes from a reply about a June 1982 sighting. Zha Leping was a student, not "Dr."; the September 1979 and May 1980 dates are confirmed by Malcolm Thompson (2020), but the March 1981 conference and Zha's election there were not. Zhang Zhousheng's "July 10–30, July 24–29" forecast window and the "twenty times the full moon" size were not found in any source. The launch review wrongly said no Proton flew in July 1981 (one flew on July 30) and omitted the July 10 Vostok launch and the ICBM tests. The computed Moon phase, a Nanjing nearest-airport figure and an ERA5 rain reading for Nanjing were replaced or removed. The Sixth Tone source is by Chen Shuyi (Shanghai Observer), not "Fan Yaqi."

🔍 View images of this case on Google →

See something inaccurate? Have additional information or sources?

Suggest an Edit →

Last Updated: October 28, 2026