Library / Essential Reading / Aliens in the Forest
// Essential Reading — ER-178

Aliens in the Forest

The Cisco Grove UFO Encounter

Case File Deep Dives Abduction & Contact Accounts

Core Thesis

Aliens in the Forest: The Cisco Grove UFO Encounter is Noe Torres and Ruben Uriarte's book-length account of the September 4–5, 1964 Cisco Grove Encounter, in which bow hunter Donald Shrum, lost in the Sierra Nevada, spent the night in a pine tree and reported lights, two silver-suited figures and robot-like objects that tried to dislodge him. The book presents the fuller version of his account given decades later — a cigar-shaped craft, goggled beings, a robot with glowing eyes and a long siege — and credits contributions from Shrum, his wife Judi, illustrator Neil Riebe and Joe Calkins. Readers should set it beside the 1964 Project Blue Book file, which records a shorter, plainer account and concludes “Other (Psychological)”; this site's case file compares the two.

About the Author

Noe Torres is a Texas-based MUFON member holding a Bachelor's degree in English and a Master's in Library Science from the University of Texas at Austin. Before turning to Cisco Grove, Torres and Ruben Uriarte had already co-authored the two principal book-length treatments of the Coyame, Mexico UFO Crash Claim, Mexico's Roswell (2007) and The Coyame Incident (2013), the latter including laboratory analysis of debris and soil from a small-plane crash field that returned inconclusive results — giving the pair an established track record of pairing direct witness access with physical-evidence documentation before applying the same method to Cisco Grove.

This site's research treats the book's most distinctive credential as its direct co-authorship credit for the witness himself: Donald R. Shrum is listed alongside Torres and Uriarte on the book's own cover, meaning the account is not a secondhand journalistic reconstruction but carries the primary witness's own direct participation in how his story was finally told in full, decades after the original 1964 encounter. Illustrator Neil Riebe contributed period-accurate artwork depicting the encounter, and Joe Calkins and Judi Shrum (Donald Shrum's wife) are also credited contributors.

This site's own research finds Torres and Uriarte's broader body of work — spanning both a Mexican crash-retrieval claim and an American tree-siege encounter separated by decades and a national border — reflects a consistent investigative method: locating and directly interviewing primary witnesses, gathering whatever physical evidence remains, and being explicit when laboratory or forensic analysis proves inconclusive rather than overstating its significance, as their own Coyame follow-up volume demonstrates.

Historical Context & Origins

The Cisco Grove encounter occurred on September 4–5, 1964, but this book was not published until 2011. In the meantime the case was known mainly through the Project Blue Book file (filed as “Sacto Area, California” and concluded “Other (Psychological)”), Victor Killick's 1964 letter in that file, and brief entries in later UFO compilations. Claims once made on this site that the Condon Committee referenced the case, and that APRO and NICAP investigated it in 1964, could not be confirmed.

The 1964 record documents Shrum's caution: he told Killick he did not want the story in the newspapers or his name made public, and the family agreed to an Air Force investigation only if there was no publicity. Shrum worked at Aerojet General's missile plant near Sacramento. This site could not confirm claims, repeated here before, that he was a missile tracking technician or that he reported the case to APRO and NICAP under the pseudonym “Mr. S.”

The book's 2011 publication also places it within the broader wave of small-press, single-case UFO investigation books published in the 2000s and 2010s, a genre this site's own essential-reading library documents extensively through titles like Torres and Uriarte's own Coyame books and comparable single-case treatments of other famous American encounters.

Core Arguments & Key Concepts

The book's central argument, built on Shrum's later testimony, is that the physical details of his encounter — an arrow that struck a figure with a metallic sound and a spark, and a vapor that overcame him — describe a genuinely anomalous event rather than a misidentification. The documented physical evidence is narrower: one arrow with a dented point, kept by the Air Force. Earlier versions of this article and of this site's case file added pseudo-technical analyses of “blue sparks” and the gas's pharmacology that rested on no examination and have been removed.

A second theme is Shrum's credibility. In 1964 both Victor Killick and the Air Force interviewers found him sincere, stable and consistent, and he sought no publicity. Claims once made here that his work made him a trained observer of aerial objects rest on a job description (“missile tracking technician”) that the 1964 documents do not give.

A third theme, reflected in the book's inclusion of Shrum's own voice directly, is that the case's emotional and psychological dimension deserves documentation alongside its physical claims: a review of the book by the Donner Summit Historical Society specifically notes that Shrum's experience left him with what the reviewer describes in modern terms as post-traumatic stress, treating the human cost of the encounter as part of the record rather than a secondary detail to the physical evidence claims.

This site's own research treats the book's greatest value as giving the primary witness direct authorial participation in his own case's most complete published account, a distinction that separates it from secondhand treatments and gives readers access to Shrum's own account with the fewest layers of interpretation between the witness and the page.

Key Cases & Evidence Discussed

The Cisco Grove Encounter (Case File #021, September 4–5, 1964) at Cisco Grove, California, is this book's sole subject. In the version the book presents, Shrum, separated from companions Vincent Alvarez and Tim Trueblood, climbed a pine, took a zig-zagging light for a rescue helicopter, and watched a large cigar-shaped craft release a smaller one; two goggled, silver-suited figures and a robot with glowing eyes came to the tree, the robot's vapor knocked him out, and he fired arrows and threw burning material at them until dawn. The 1964 Air Force file records a plainer account — three round lights, figures with protruding eyes and no neck, arrows that “failed to distract” them, a blackout until dawn, and companions who suggested a meteorite — and this site's case file sets the two side by side.

Critical Reception & Controversies

On Goodreads, the book carries a 3.46-out-of-5 average from 48 ratings and 10 written reviews (checked August 2026) — a substantial sample by the standards of small-press single-case UFO books, and one that reflects a genuinely mixed reception. Positive reviewers praised it as "not your typical saucer story" and "probably the most detailed account you are going to find on this event," with one calling it a "fascinating story" that "provides great insights on extraterrestrial behaviour." Critical reviewers focused specifically on the book's editing and pacing rather than its underlying case material, with multiple readers noting that "the same information and even the same quotes are used repeatedly," one describing it as "poorly written (so much repetition throughout the book that it genuinely starts to become confusing) and bulked out unreasonably."

This site's research attempted to verify an Amazon rating for this title but Amazon's bot-detection system repeatedly blocked automated requests to the listing during this session, returning a CAPTCHA challenge across multiple attempts. Per this site's own Amazon Rating Display Protocol, this gap is disclosed honestly here rather than fabricated or silently omitted.

A review from the Donner Summit Historical Society — a local historical organization based near the actual Sierra Nevada location of the encounter — described the 186-page book as concise and well-illustrated with maps, presenting Shrum's account straightforwardly without either endorsing or dismissing its underlying claims, and specifically noting the book's second half documents Shrum's efforts to report the incident to the Air Force. This site's research treats a geographically local historical society's willingness to review the book neutrally, on its own terms, as a modest but genuine indicator of the case's continued local as well as ufological significance.

Influence & Legacy

On this site the book is cited in the Cisco Grove case file as the source of the later, fuller version of Shrum's account, set alongside the 1964 Project Blue Book record.

The case's continued cultural relevance is well documented independent of the book itself: this site's research found the encounter has been covered by the popular YouTube series "The Why Files" in its episode "Mystery in Cisco Grove: Don Shrum's Encounter with UFOs, Aliens and Robots," and by the long-running paranormal podcast "Astonishing Legends" in its episode "Battle at Cisco Grove" — both more than a decade after this book's original publication, evidence that Torres, Uriarte, and Shrum's 2011 account remains the reference point subsequent popular treatments of the case return to.

Torres and Uriarte's parallel body of work on the Coyame, Mexico UFO Crash Claim gives this book additional context within their broader career: this site's own research finds the pair have consistently prioritized direct witness access and physical-evidence documentation across genuinely different kinds of cases — an alleged 1974 aircraft crash-retrieval in Mexico and a 1964 wilderness tree-siege in California — suggesting a consistent methodological commitment rather than a single-case specialization.

The Book

Aliens in the Forest cover art

Aliens in the Forest

The Cisco Grove UFO Encounter

Original Publication
2011, Roswell Books
Edition Cited
Roswell Books 2011 paperback, 1st ed.
ISBN-13
9781467945554
Genre
Case Investigation & Witness Testimony
Find on Amazon →

As an Amazon Associate, OverClassified may earn from qualifying purchases made through this link, at no extra cost to you.

Why This Is Essential Reading

Aliens in the Forest: The Cisco Grove UFO Encounter earns its place on this list as the only book-length account of one of American ufology's most dramatic close-encounter reports, distinguished specifically by witness Donald Shrum's own direct co-authorship credit. Noe Torres and Ruben Uriarte's established method of pairing direct witness testimony with physical-evidence documentation, already demonstrated in their earlier Coyame investigation, gives this site's own Cisco Grove case file exactly the kind of primary-source grounding its detailed technical analysis of the case's arrows, sparks, and incapacitating gas depends on. Its solid but genuinely mixed 3.46/5 Goodreads reception — praised for detail, criticized for repetitive editing — is disclosed honestly here rather than smoothed into an artificially positive summary. Read as the fullest statement of Donald Shrum's later account of his night in a Sierra Nevada pine tree, this book is essential specifically because it preserved a primary witness's testimony in full, decades after professional fear had originally forced him into near-total public silence.

Related Cases & Theories

Essential Viewing

Sources Cited

  • Torres, Noe, Uriarte, Ruben, and Shrum, Donald R. Aliens in the Forest: The Cisco Grove UFO Encounter. Roswell Books, 2011 (ISBN 978-1-4679-4555-4, illustrated by Neil Riebe, cited here).
  • "Aliens in the Forest: The Cisco Grove UFO Encounter." Goodreads (rating 3.46/5, 48 ratings, 10 written reviews quoted, checked August 2026). goodreads.com
  • "Aliens in the Forest." AbeBooks (ISBN 9781467945554, marketplace listing photograph used for this article's cover image). abebooks.com
  • "Aliens in the Forest." Donner Summit Historical Society (independent book review from a historical society based near the encounter's Sierra Nevada location). donnersummithistoricalsociety.org
  • "Mystery in Cisco Grove: Don Shrum's Encounter with UFOs, Aliens and Robots." The Why Files, YouTube (video verified via oEmbed). youtube.com
  • This site's own resources library: Full Reading List, where this exact 2011 edition is cited across this site's Cisco Grove case-file page.
  • This site's own key-figures entry: Noe Torres, for his full biography and site-wide case connections.
  • This site's own key-figures entry: Ruben Uriarte, for his full biography and site-wide case connections.
  • This site's own key-figures entry: Donald Shrum, the case's primary witness and this book's co-credited author.
  • This site's own case file: Cisco Grove Encounter (1964), this book's exclusive subject.
  • This site's own case file: Coyame, Mexico UFO Crash Claim, Torres and Uriarte's other major book-length investigation.
  • Astonishing Legends. "Ep 246: Battle at Cisco Grove" (independent podcast coverage of the case, demonstrating its continued reference status). astonishinglegends.com

Have corrections, additional research, or peer-reviewed sources? Help improve this entry.

Suggest an Edit