CASE FILE #317 DISPUTED Credibility50/100

Collahuasi Mine UFO Sighting

In mid-April 2013, approximately 35 workers at the Collahuasi copper mine — one of the world's largest, sitting at roughly 4,200–4,300 meters in the Chilean Andes — watched a brilliant, flattened silvery disc hover, rise, descend, and drift in short horizontal segments roughly 600 meters above the mine site for one to two hours (accounts differ) before departing to the east. One of the technicians photographed it twice on a basic compact camera. About ten months later the sighting and photographs were reported to Chile's CEFAA — the Comité de Estudios de Fenómenos Aéreos Anómalos, one of the only standing national government agencies on Earth dedicated to investigating anomalous aerial phenomena — and officials ruled out lenticular cloud, drones, weather balloons, and known or experimental aircraft. The study CEFAA released on July 3, 2014 concluded that it was “an extremely interesting object or phenomenon” that “would be classified as a UFO in the proper sense,” though director Ricardo Bermúdez cautioned that this was the determination of one analyst.

Bottom line

Best explanation
Still unidentified. Chile’s official committee, CEFAA, ruled out lenticular cloud, drones, weather balloons and known or experimental aircraft, without claiming to know what it was. A photographic hoax is the one ordinary explanation not ruled out.
Why “Disputed”
About 35 workers watched it, and the committee methodically eliminated the usual explanations. But no witness was ever named or interviewed by an investigator, the report arrived roughly ten months later, and one basic camera produced the entire record.
What would change it
A forensic analysis of the original camera files and their chain of custody, or witnesses interviewed directly on the record. No such analysis has been published, and the witnesses declined CEFAA’s follow-up.
Date
Mid-April 2013 (exact date never publicly disclosed)
Location
Collahuasi copper mine, Pica commune, Tarapacá Region, northern Chile
Craft Type
Flattened metallic disc, 5–10 m diameter, briefly appearing as a luminous globe
Witnesses
~35 mine personnel observed it; a group of technicians (four, per Kean) watched it and one photographed it (names never released)
Evidence
2 still photographs (Samsung Kenox S860 compact camera); no video, no radar, no physical trace
Classification
Hynek Daylight Disc (DD); CEFAA's own formal classification: Unidentified Flying Object
Time
Approx. midday, per shadow-angle analysis of the photographs
Weather
Clear, cloudless sky; CEFAA's own consulting meteorologist ruled out lenticular cloud formation
The Collahuasi copper mine's high-altitude open-pit operations in the Tarapacá Region of northern Chile, photographed in 2016
View more photographs on Google Images →
Click to view photographs on Google Images →

Pictured: the Collahuasi mine's open-pit operations in the high Andes of Chile's Tarapacá Region, photographed by Diego Delso in February 2016 — the real mine site at the center of this case, not the disputed object itself. No public-domain or rights-clear photograph of the original two 2013 witness images (still held privately and by CEFAA) is known to be freely licensed for reproduction here. (CC BY-SA 4.0, Diego Delso, delso.photo.)

Theoretical Alignment

🛸
Extraterrestrial (ETH)
45% Alignment
🌀
Interdimensional (IDH)
5% Alignment
🧠
Psycho-Social (PSH)
22% Alignment

This case sits closer to genuine ambiguity than most files in this catalog. The Extraterrestrial Hypothesis (ETH) draws real, if partial, support: a structured, apparently solid disc, independently photographed twice, displaying controlled-looking vertical and horizontal repositioning over two hours in front of dozens of technically literate industrial workers, with a formal government investigation unable to find any conventional match — a genuinely unusual evidentiary profile. It falls well short of full alignment, though, because nothing in the record establishes intelligent non-human origin specifically; CEFAA's own conclusion is a narrower and more modest one — “unidentified,” not “alien.” The Interdimensional Hypothesis (IDH) finds almost nothing to work with: no claim of dimensional transition, missing time, consciousness interaction, or any of the phenomenology that IDH cases typically involve. Psycho-Social Hypothesis (PSH) alignment is rated speculative rather than absent for a specific, honest reason distinct from most PSH ratings on this site: it is not that the sighting looks like a misperceived mundane object, but that the case's real evidentiary chain — a single photographer, a roughly ten-month delay before the photos reached investigators, and witnesses who declined all further cooperation — leaves open, if unproven, questions about how the story was assembled and transmitted before CEFAA ever saw it.

Background

Chile's Comité de Estudios de Fenómenos Aéreos Anómalos (CEFAA) is one of a small handful of standing national government bodies anywhere in the world formally chartered to investigate unidentified aerial phenomena, and the Collahuasi case sits squarely within its most institutionally unusual feature: unlike the U.S. Department of Defense's AARO or France's GEIPAN, which sit inside a defense ministry or a national space agency respectively, CEFAA was established by resolution of Chile's Dirección General de Aeronáutica Civil (DGAC) — the country's civil aviation authority, roughly Chile's equivalent of the U.S. FAA — on October 3, 1997, explicitly framed around aviation safety rather than defense or scientific curiosity. Enzo Di Nocera led the committee in its first year; retired Air Force brigadier general Ricardo Bermúdez Sanhueza then directed it across two separate terms (1998–2002 and 2009–2016, with a 2002–2008 dormancy period under an intervening director in between), building it into what DGAC's own published history calls a model other countries' agencies have looked to. CEFAA combines DGAC technical staff with volunteer scientists drawn from Chilean universities and observers from every branch of the armed forces and national police, evaluating citizen- and pilot-submitted reports — descriptions, photographs, video — against meteorological, astronomical, and aviation data before issuing a formal conclusion. The agency is genuinely selective: across the reports it has logged since 1998, CEFAA's own director has stated that only about 3% are ever formally classified as instances the committee cannot explain by conventional means: no known aircraft, no balloon, no astronomical object, no atmospheric phenomenon. The Collahuasi case is one of that small minority. In 2010 CEFAA became an independent unit reporting directly to DGAC's own general secretariat rather than remaining housed inside the Air Force Technical School, and by September 2021 — under its newer name, SEFAA (Sección de Estudios de Fenómenos Aéreos Anómalos) — the agency had logged 1,675 total case reports since its founding, publishing investigated and resolved cases on its own website on a quarterly basis since 2020, a practice that began after the Collahuasi case was already several years old and therefore does not include it in that online archive.

The mine itself is real and enormous. Compañía Minera Doña Inés de Collahuasi SCM operates one of the largest copper deposits on Earth — an estimated 3.93 billion tonnes of ore grading 0.66% copper — from open-pit workings (principally the Rosario and Ujina pits) in the high Andean plateau of the Pica commune, Tarapacá Region, roughly 180 km southeast of the port city of Iquique, at an elevation the mine's own operator and CEFAA's witnesses place at approximately 4,200 to 4,300 meters. It is jointly owned by Anglo American plc (44%), Glencore plc (44%), and a Mitsui & Co.-led consortium, Japan Collahuasi Resources (12%), and produced roughly 560,000 tonnes of copper in 2018 alone, placing it consistently among the handful of largest copper mines on the planet. Small-scale mining activity in the area dates back to at least 1905–1930, but the modern industrial-scale operation that exists today, with its large resident workforce rotating through remote high-altitude shifts, is a product of the 1990s expansion that made Collahuasi one of Chile's flagship mining assets — and, by extension, the kind of large, technically staffed, security-conscious industrial site where an anomalous daylight sighting is unusually likely to be witnessed by dozens of people at once, yet also unusually likely to go unreported for a long time given the operational and reputational sensitivities of a major multinational mining concession.

Complete Timeline

DateEvent
October 3, 1997CEFAA is formally established by DGAC resolution; from 1998 it is led by retired Air Force Brig. Gen. Ricardo Bermúdez.
Mid-April 2013Around midday (per later shadow-angle analysis), a bright, flattened disc is sighted hovering and maneuvering roughly 600 meters above the Collahuasi mine site for about two hours; approximately 35 mine personnel observe it across the facility.
Same dayA group of technicians specializing in electricity, electronics, and fluid control watch the object; one of them photographs it twice on a Samsung Kenox S860 compact digital camera before it departs toward the east.
April 2013–early 2014The witnesses decide to keep the sighting private; the photographer later shows the pictures to the mine's chief engineer, who asks for copies.
February 22, 2014The group's chief reports the sighting to CEFAA, sending the photographs and the witnesses' information — roughly ten months after the sighting itself.
Spring 2014DGAC's meteorological office confirms a clear sky and rules out lenticular cloud; a CEFAA image analyst examines the two photographs.
June 29 – July 3, 2014La Tercera (June 29) and El Mostrador (July 1) publish the case and the photograph; CEFAA releases its study on July 3.
July 7, 2014BioBioChile and other Chilean outlets report DGAC/CEFAA's formal acknowledgment that it has no conventional explanation for the object.
Mid-to-late 2014International wire and outlet pickup (HuffPost, Fox News, Inquisitr, and others) carries the case to a global audience, including on-record comment from independent U.S. physicist Bruce Maccabee.
April–May 2015Recycled coverage (Yahoo! News UK, Fox News Latino, Yibada) claims CEFAA called the object “not made by man.” On May 13, 2015 HuffPost reports CEFAA's José Lay rejecting that framing: “We do not know its origin or its nature.”
Since 2015This file found no further public follow-up investigation of the Collahuasi case by CEFAA/SEFAA; the case remains formally closed as unidentified, with no revision to its original classification.

The Sighting: Two Hours Above the Atacama Plateau

The Collahuasi mine sits in one of the most extreme working environments in industrial Chile: a high Andean plateau at roughly 4,200 to 4,300 meters elevation, thin dry air, intense unfiltered sunlight, and some of the clearest, most cloudless skies anywhere on the planet — the same optical clarity that makes the wider Atacama region a magnet for the world's most sensitive ground-based astronomical observatories. It was against that backdrop, sometime in mid-April 2013, that workers at the mine first noticed an object in the sky that did not match anything routinely seen at the site. Witnesses described a flattened, brilliantly colored, silvery disc approximately 5 to 10 meters in diameter, hovering at an estimated 600 meters above the ground and holding position for extended stretches before making slow, incremental vertical and horizontal repositioning — rising, descending, and drifting sideways in short segments rather than any single continuous flight path. At points during the roughly two-hour observation, several witnesses reported the object's appearance shifting: what read most consistently as a static, silvery disc briefly took on the look of a glowing, balloon-like sphere before reverting to its more clearly defined disc shape. According to the most detailed independent account of the case's chronology, the object eventually departed toward the east, ending the sighting.

Reports differ, in a way this file treats honestly rather than glossing over, on exactly how many people saw it. Widely circulated Chilean press coverage (El Mostrador, La Tercera, coverage syndicated through Univision) places the number at approximately 35 workers and professionals across the mine site who observed the phenomenon during the two-hour window. Separately, Leslie Kean's English-language report, drawing on CEFAA's released case summary, describes a core group of four technicians — specialists in electricity, electronics, and fluid control, professions CEFAA's own report characterized as bringing unusually pragmatic, technically literate mindsets to the encounter — who tracked the object most directly, one of whom photographed it. Kean also gives a shorter duration, “more than an hour,” and Fox News about an hour, against the two hours in the Chilean press. The most coherent reading of both figures together, consistent with how a sighting would unfold across a sprawling, multi-pit industrial site with workers spread across different elevations and vantage points, is that the four technicians formed the closest, most sustained, and best-documented group of observers, while the wider total of roughly 35 reflects the larger number of personnel elsewhere on site who also glimpsed the object at some point during its two hours overhead without necessarily tracking it as continuously or photographing it themselves.

The two surviving photographs, taken on an ordinary Samsung Kenox S860 — a modest, consumer-grade compact digital camera, not any kind of specialized or military-grade optical equipment — became the entire physical evidentiary record of the case. Later shadow-angle analysis by CEFAA's own investigators placed the time of the photographs at approximately midday. No video was ever recorded, no second independent camera or vantage point exists in the public record, and no radar or other instrumented data corroborates the sighting in any way — the case, from beginning to end, rests entirely on witness testimony and those two still images.

From Silence to Disclosure: How the Photos Reached CEFAA

What happened between the sighting and its becoming public is, on its own, one of the case's more genuinely unusual features. Rather than reporting the object immediately — the pattern CEFAA's process is generally built around, since most of its case intake comes from pilots and aviation personnel filing contemporaneous reports — the Collahuasi witnesses decided to keep the sighting to themselves. According to Leslie Kean's account, the photographer later showed the pictures to the mine's chief engineer, who asked for copies. La Tercera reports that the group's chief reported the sighting to CEFAA on February 22, 2014 — roughly ten months after the actual sighting — and Kean says the engineer sent the images with the information the witnesses had given him. By the time Chilean and international press picked up the story at the end of June 2014, the case was more than a year old. El Mostrador described the analysis as lasting a year; the study itself was released on July 3, 2014, a little over four months after the February report.

This delay carries real evidentiary weight and this file does not minimize it: a lengthy gap between an event and its first formal report is, across UAP investigation generally, one of the classic risk factors for embellishment, confused recollection, or fabrication, and it is compounded here by a second limitation — CEFAA's José Lay told Kean that “the witnesses were not willing to cooperate. We tried to contact them, and we got no reply.” No witness in this case has ever been named publicly, and none has given an on-record, first-person account beyond what was relayed secondhand through the mine's own internal chain before reaching CEFAA. That combination — genuine photographic evidence and a formal government review, set against a materially compromised chain of custody and zero direct investigator access to any primary witness — is precisely why this file's credibility assessment lands in the middle of this site's range rather than at either extreme.

CEFAA's Multi-Disciplinary Analysis

Once the material reached CEFAA, the agency followed its standard multi-disciplinary review process, distributing the two photographs to a consulting meteorologist and to its photo-analysis specialists working in parallel. When the study was released, CEFAA director Ricardo Bermúdez told Kean: “We recognize that this is the determination of only one CEFFA analyst among several. So we still must be cautious.” He called a meeting of the committee's scientific panel for the following week; this file found no published outcome from that meeting.

Ruling Out the Mundane

The meteorological review specifically examined whether the object could be explained as a lenticular cloud — a lens-shaped atmospheric formation common in mountainous terrain and one of the most frequent mundane explanations for disc-shaped sighting reports worldwide — and ruled it out: DGAC's meteorological office confirmed “an absolute clear sky at that time,” according to Kean, and the CEFAA report describes the weather conditions as outstanding. Separately, CEFAA's international affairs director, José Lay, addressed the era's obvious alternative explanation directly: drones. “People in that zone know about drones,” he told Kean. “Fishing companies use drones and they make a lot of noise. This was definitely not a drone.” Officials also ruled out experimental aircraft, planes, and weather balloons; no flight records or other documentation behind those eliminations has been published.

What the Photo Analysis Found

CEFAA's image analysts applied digital filtering to the two surviving photographs to bring out additional structural and luminosity detail beyond what was visible to the naked eye. In the second and more detailed of the two images, the filtered analysis distinguished two separate visual elements: a circular ring forming the object's outer perimeter, and a raised, roughly hemispherical structure at its center — a description broadly consistent with witnesses' own account of a disc that at times appeared to bulge or brighten toward its middle. The luminosity analysis produced the report's most striking technical finding: CEFAA's analysts concluded the object's brightness pattern was inconsistent with simple reflected sunlight, describing instead an intensely bright central point together with four faint luminous rays radiating outward, a pattern the report characterized as suggestive of the object emitting its own light from an internal, comparatively powerful source rather than merely catching and reflecting the sun. Compounding that finding, the analysts also noted that the brightest light in the image appeared to originate from the object's underside — the side that, under a midday overhead sun and simple solar reflection, would ordinarily be expected to sit in shadow rather than glow. Taken together, CEFAA's own report characterized the object as “an extremely interesting object or phenomenon” that “would be classified as a UFO in the proper sense” — a conclusion that, as Bermúdez stressed at the time, rested on one analyst's work.

Official Findings and Public Reaction

Ricardo Bermúdez, CEFAA's director (1998–2002 and again from 2009), described the object to the Chilean press in July 2014: “Era un disco plateado, de unos diez metros de diámetro” (“It was a silver disc, about ten meters in diameter”). He also told La Tercera that “la figura más evidente fue la de disco plateado, fijo, estático” (“the most evident shape was that of a silver disc, fixed, static”), and said that the object “no calza con nada conocido” (“doesn't match anything known”). Bermúdez placed the case within Chile's own broader UFO-reporting statistics, noting it fell among the roughly 3% of reports CEFAA has received since 1998 that the agency has formally been unable to explain, and framed Chile's approach as unusually open by international standards, saying Chile was “el único país donde existe total transparencia” (“the only country where there is total transparency”) and that “nosotros no tenemos secretos” (“we have no secrets”) — a claim grounded in CEFAA's genuinely unusual institutional position as a civilian, non-military aviation-safety body rather than a classified defense program.

José Lay, CEFAA's international affairs director, offered a more measured framing in May 2015, when recycled reports claimed CEFAA had called the object “not made by man”: “We do not know its origin or its nature,” he told HuffPost, adding that the press claims “twisted what we ever declared about this case.” He explicitly declined to characterize the object as extraterrestrial or as necessarily beyond human manufacturing capability — only as unidentified. That distinction matters for how this file assesses the case: CEFAA's own institutional position, both in the Collahuasi report and consistently across its public statements on other cases, has never been that its unexplained cases prove non-human visitation, only that a specific, rigorous process of elimination failed to produce a conventional match.

Independent commentary from outside CEFAA was cautious. Retired U.S. Navy physicist Bruce Maccabee, a longtime independent UFO photo analyst with decades of experience examining disputed imagery, reviewed the Collahuasi photographs and told Kean: “This is clearly not a normal thing seen in the sky (bird, plane, cloud, etc.).” “That makes it either the real thing – UFO – or a hoax,” he added; “it doesn't appear to be a hoax, although the inability to question witnesses does reduce the credibility.” He described a very bright hemispherical shape, convex downward, in the second image, suggested it was “possibly a UFO enveloped in a cloud of vapor,” and noted that the object had moved a considerable distance between the two photographs. His comments were a judgment from the published images, not a forensic analysis of the original files.

Context: CEFAA and Chile's Unique Government UAP Program

The Collahuasi case is best understood not as an isolated sighting but as one data point inside a much larger, genuinely unusual institutional experiment. Chile is one of a very small number of countries — alongside France's CNES-run GEIPAN and, more recently and narrowly, the U.S. Department of Defense's AARO — to maintain an ongoing, named, government-staffed body specifically tasked with investigating UAP reports as a standing function rather than an occasional ad hoc inquiry. CEFAA's placement inside DGAC, Chile's civil aviation regulator, rather than inside the Chilean Air Force's intelligence apparatus or a classified defense program, is itself part of why the agency has been able to publish findings, brand names, and even internal disagreements relatively openly compared to most other countries' UAP-adjacent efforts.

The comparison is worth drawing out in more detail, because it directly bears on why a private industrial site like Collahuasi ended up inside CEFAA's jurisdiction at all rather than a military one. France's GEIPAN (Groupe d'Études et d'Information sur les Phénomènes Aérospatiaux Non identifiés) has operated continuously since 1977 as a unit of CNES, the French national space agency, publishing its own case catalog with a four-tier classification system open to public search — a scientific, civilian-agency posture broadly similar to CEFAA's own. The U.S. Department of Defense's All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office (AARO), by contrast, is a much newer creation, established following the 2022 National Defense Authorization Act and operating under the Office of the Under Secretary of Defense for Intelligence and Security in coordination with the Office of the Director of National Intelligence — a defense- and intelligence-community structure fundamentally different from CEFAA's civil-aviation-safety framing. CEFAA's nearly three-decade continuous operation inside a civilian regulator, publishing named-director statements and, since 2020, quarterly case releases, sits closer in spirit to GEIPAN's open scientific posture than to AARO's classified, national-security-driven one — and it is that civilian, safety-first framing, not any military or intelligence mandate, that explains why a case involving a private multinational mining concession rather than any defense installation fell naturally within CEFAA's jurisdiction in the first place. This site's own catalog already documents two other CEFAA-investigated Chilean cases that follow a broadly similar pattern — a real, photographed or filmed anomaly at an industrial or military site, an internal CEFAA review, and a final classification of unresolved rather than solved — in the El Bosque Air Base UFO Video (November 2010) and the Chilean Navy Helicopter Video (November 2014). Collahuasi falls between the two in date and shares their structural signature: a credentialed institutional witness base, a documented CEFAA review process explicitly designed to rule out the mundane before ever entertaining the exotic, and a formal conclusion that stops short of endorsing any specific origin for the object while declining to offer one that fits known aircraft, weather, or human technology either.

The Five Observables Assessment

The Five Observables framework, developed from U.S. military and intelligence-community characterizations of genuinely anomalous flight performance, is applied here to the object's reported behavior as described by witnesses and by CEFAA's own report:

🔽
Anti-Gravity Lift
Speculative
⚡
Instant Accel.
Absent
💨
Hypersonic
Absent
👁️
Low Observability
Absent
🌊
Trans-Medium
Absent

Assessment: This case rates as a comparatively modest, non-dramatic entry against the Five Observables framework, and this file treats that honestly rather than inflating the rating to match the case's overall credibility score. Anti-Gravity Lift is rated speculative rather than present because the object reportedly held stationary or near-stationary positions for extended stretches with no visible means of propulsion or support — genuinely consistent with a hovering craft, but never instrumented or measured, and equally consistent with a slow-drifting object of an entirely different, undetermined nature. Every other observable rates absent on the object's own reported behavior: the described vertical and horizontal repositioning happened in slow, incremental “short segments” rather than any instant, high-g acceleration; no velocity data of any kind exists to support a hypersonic rating; the object was, by every account, extremely visible — bright, colorful, and watched continuously by dozens of people in broad daylight for two hours, the functional opposite of a low-observable signature; and nothing in the case involves any transition between air, water, or ground. Collahuasi's evidentiary interest lies almost entirely in its witness count, its documented government investigation, and its two photographs — not in any exotic flight-performance claim.

Evidence Assessment

Supporting Anomalous Origin

  • Approximately 35 workers across a large industrial site independently observed the object over a sustained two-hour period, with a core group of four technically trained technicians tracking and photographing it directly.
  • DGAC's meteorological office and a CEFAA image analyst were unable to identify the object as a lenticular cloud, drone, known or experimental aircraft, or weather balloon.
  • Digital filtering of the surviving photograph revealed luminosity characteristics — an intensely bright center, four faint radiating rays, and light appearing to originate from the object's shadowed underside — that CEFAA's analysts concluded were inconsistent with simple solar reflection.
  • Independent physicist Bruce Maccabee, reviewing the published photographs from outside CEFAA, said the case “doesn't appear to be a hoax,” while noting that the inability to question witnesses reduces its credibility.
  • The sighting occurred under confirmed clear, cloudless skies at extreme altitude — among the best atmospheric visibility conditions anywhere on Earth — reducing the likelihood of common optical-distortion explanations.

Supporting Conventional Explanation or Caution

  • Nearly ten months passed between the sighting and CEFAA first receiving any formal report or the photographs, a substantial gap during which memory, retelling, and image handling all could have introduced errors before any government investigator ever saw the material.
  • No witness has ever been publicly named, and according to the most detailed account of the case, the witnesses declined further cooperation and did not respond to CEFAA's attempts at direct follow-up contact — meaning no primary account was ever taken directly by an investigator.
  • Only one photographer and one camera (a basic consumer compact) produced the entire physical evidentiary record; no second independent camera, no video, and no radar or instrumented corroboration exists anywhere in the public record.
  • CEFAA's report itself never claims to identify the object's true nature or origin — only that no conventional match was found, a materially narrower and more modest finding than “confirmed anomalous craft.”
  • No detailed, published, independent skeptical technical rebuttal of the Collahuasi case specifically has been identified in this file's research, despite a genuine search effort — a gap that cuts both ways: it means the case's photographic evidence has never been directly, technically challenged in public, but also that it has not withstood the kind of adversarial scrutiny some other well-known cases have.

Why "Disputed"

This case earns a Disputed stamp because a well-witnessed sighting and a methodical official process of elimination are matched by equally specific weaknesses in how the evidence reached investigators. About 35 mine personnel saw the object by the Chilean press's count (four technicians in the CEFAA report), and one technician photographed it twice. DGAC's meteorological office confirmed a clear sky and ruled out lenticular cloud; CEFAA's international affairs director rejected drones, citing local familiarity with them; and officials also ruled out experimental aircraft, planes, and weather balloons. Digital filtering of the photographs surfaced structural and luminosity detail — not simply witness impression — and an independent outside physicist judged from the published images that the case did not appear to be a hoax, while noting that the inability to question witnesses reduces its credibility.

It does not earn a Credible stamp because those weaknesses go to the heart of the record. The roughly ten-month delay before CEFAA received any report is an unaddressed weak point in the chain of custody. No witness has ever been named, spoken on the record, or been interviewed by an investigator, and the witnesses did not answer CEFAA's attempts at follow-up, so all of the testimony is secondhand. One photographer and one basic camera produced the entire physical record, with no video, second vantage point, or instrumented data to cross-check it; no forensic analysis of the original camera files, or flight records behind the aircraft eliminations, has been published. CEFAA's own director cautioned that the UFO finding was one analyst's determination, and the agency's conclusion is narrower than headlines describing an “officially recognized UFO” suggest: it found no conventional match, but has never claimed to know the object's origin or nature.

It is not Debunked because no conventional explanation has been shown to fit. The one ordinary candidate still standing is a photographic hoax, and the case's weaknesses are exactly the conditions under which a hoax is easiest to construct and hardest to disprove; but the reviews of the images found no sign of manipulation, and this file has found no published skeptical technical rebuttal of the case. That leaves it contested rather than resolved in either direction.

Sensor & Instrumentation Detection Profile

Detection in this case was limited entirely to unaided human vision and a single consumer-grade compact digital camera, the Samsung Kenox S860, which produced the two surviving still photographs. No radar of any kind — military, civil aviation, or the mine's own private security or vehicle-tracking systems — recorded the object; Collahuasi, as a private industrial site rather than an airport or military installation, has no dedicated air-surveillance radar coverage of its own, and no external radar facility's data has ever been cited in connection with this case. No infrared, multispectral, or video recording exists. This is a significant limitation shared with many civilian UFO sightings of this era: the entire evidentiary record depends on the optical output of one ordinary camera, reviewed after the fact by CEFAA's photo analysts using digital filtering rather than any specialized imaging instrument deployed at the time of the sighting itself. CEFAA's own review process compensated for this limitation as best it could by cross-referencing the images against independently verifiable weather data and known aviation and drone activity records, rather than relying on the photographs in isolation — but no amount of after-the-fact analysis substitutes for the radar, video, or multi-instrument corroboration this site's higher-scoring cases typically possess.

Environmental & Geospatial Context

The Collahuasi mine sits at approximately 4,200 to 4,300 meters elevation on the high Andean plateau of northern Chile's Tarapacá Region, in one of the driest, clearest-skied environments on Earth — the same broader Atacama desert corridor that hosts major international astronomical observatories precisely because of its exceptional atmospheric transparency and minimal light pollution. CEFAA's own consulting meteorologist confirmed clear, cloudless conditions at the time of the sighting, a finding that both ruled out lenticular cloud formation as an explanation and, more generally, means the object was observed under close to ideal visual conditions rather than through haze, cloud cover, or atmospheric distortion that might otherwise explain an ambiguous shape as a misperceived mundane object. Shadow-angle analysis of the surviving photographs placed the sighting at approximately midday, meaning the object was observed under strong, direct, high-altitude equatorial-adjacent sunlight — conditions that make CEFAA's own finding of anomalous, non-reflective luminosity from the object's underside particularly notable, since simple solar reflection is generally easiest to demonstrate or rule out under exactly this kind of strong, unambiguous overhead lighting. The mine's extreme altitude and remoteness also mean the sighting occurred far from any civilian airport, military airfield, or populated town, reducing (though not eliminating) the likelihood of routine aviation traffic being mistaken for the object, while simultaneously reducing the odds that a second, independent camera or witness group beyond the mine's own workforce was ever in a position to corroborate it.

Observer Credibility & Occupational Profile

The witnesses in this case are, in aggregate, a genuinely credible professional population, even though none can be individually assessed by name. The core group of four technicians who tracked the object, one of whom photographed it, were, per CEFAA's own case summary, specialists in electricity, electronics, and fluid control — trades that require exactly the kind of practical, hands-on technical literacy least likely to mistake ordinary industrial equipment, aircraft lighting, or atmospheric phenomena for something genuinely anomalous, and CEFAA's own report specifically characterized them as bringing pragmatic, skeptical mindsets to the encounter rather than any predisposition toward an exotic interpretation. The wider group of roughly 35 additional personnel who reportedly observed the object elsewhere across the mine site situates this as a substantial multi-witness event at a single large, tightly managed industrial facility — the kind of setting where a two-hour aerial anomaly is difficult for a large workforce to collectively misperceive or fabricate in coordination, given the mine's normal security, shift-reporting, and operational discipline.

Set against that strength is a real, specific weakness this file does not minimize: none of the witnesses, including the four core technicians, has ever been named publicly, given an on-record interview, or spoken directly to a CEFAA investigator. Every account of what was seen reaches the public only through CEFAA's own secondhand case summary and subsequent press coverage, filtered through an internal chain that took roughly ten months to reach the agency in the first place. That combination — a technically credible occupational profile at scale, but zero primary, first-person, on-record testimony — is unusual even among this site's more thinly documented cases and is a central reason this file's credibility score sits in the middle of this site's range rather than near either extreme.

There is also an occupational-incentive argument worth making explicit rather than leaving implicit. Large-scale industrial mining operations like Collahuasi run under strict safety, security, and shift-accountability protocols, precisely because a joint venture of this size — jointly owned by two of the world's largest mining and commodities companies — carries substantial commercial and regulatory incentive to avoid operational disruption, false alarms, or reputational embarrassment. If the Chilean press figure of 35 observers is accurate, a coordinated fabrication involving dozens of technically trained personnel across a securely managed worksite would represent an unusually elaborate and professionally risky hoax for workers with no obvious motive to manufacture one. That reasoning does not rule out honest collective misperception of a genuinely mundane stimulus, which remains possible regardless of witness sincerity, but it meaningfully raises the bar for any explanation resting on deliberate fabrication by the witnesses themselves, as distinct from the separate and more narrowly bounded question of whether the two photographs specifically were altered after the fact.

Physical & Material Assays

No physical evidence of any kind exists in this case, and none was ever claimed. The object was never approached, no debris or trace material was recovered from the mine site, and nothing beyond the two photographs and witness recollection was ever submitted to CEFAA for analysis. This is consistent with the great majority of visual and photographic UFO sightings generally, and it is a structural limitation of the case rather than a gap in this file's own research: there was simply nothing physical to test.

Historical Precedents & Archive Matches

Collahuasi fits into a well-documented broader pattern of Chilean UFO reporting that both predates and postdates it. Chilean journalist Patricio Abusleme's book-length survey of the country's UFO history documents thirteen especially prominent Chilean cases spanning 1956 to 1998 alone, witnessed across the country's full geographic range from its far northern deserts to the Antarctic research stations of its southernmost territory — a reporting density Chilean researchers and CEFAA officials themselves have repeatedly pointed to as part of why the country eventually institutionalized a standing investigative body rather than treating each report as an isolated curiosity. Within this site's own catalog specifically, Collahuasi is one of three CEFAA-investigated cases sharing a common structural pattern — a photographed or filmed anomaly at an industrial or military installation, credentialed institutional witnesses, and a CEFAA review ending in an unresolved classification rather than either confirmation or debunking — alongside the November 2010 El Bosque Air Base UFO Video and the November 2014 Chilean Navy Helicopter Video. All three cases were investigated by the same agency under the same director for at least part of their review, and all three ultimately reached the same formal outcome: a documented, methodical process of elimination against known explanations, followed by an honest declination to identify what was actually observed.

Material Analysis

There is no recovered physical or trace material evidence in this case to analyze, and there could not be: the object was observed only from a distance of roughly 600 meters and was never approached, landed, or in any way physically accessible to witnesses. The only material available for analysis of any kind is the documentary record itself — the two surviving photographs, CEFAA's own written case findings, and the independently verifiable meteorological data for the date and location of the sighting. All of CEFAA's own analytical findings on the images point toward genuine ambiguity rather than a clear resolution in either direction: real, structured visual detail (a defined ring perimeter, a raised central element) and a luminosity signature the agency's analysts concluded was inconsistent with simple sunlight reflection, but nothing rising to confirmed physical or forensic proof of any origin, terrestrial or otherwise.

Supporting Non-Terrestrial or Genuinely Anomalous Origin

  • CEFAA's digital-filter photo analysis concluded the object's luminosity pattern — an intense central point, four faint radiating rays, and apparent light from its shadowed underside — was inconsistent with simple solar reflection off a conventional surface.
  • No terrestrial aircraft, drone, balloon, or cloud formation consistent with the object's reported appearance, duration, and movement was ever identified despite CEFAA's review.

Supporting Terrestrial or Conventional Origin

  • The entire physical record consists of two photographs from a single basic consumer camera, with no physical sample, debris, or trace material of any kind ever recovered or even claimed to exist.
  • CEFAA's own analysts worked exclusively from two static images taken well after the fact; no controlled, contemporaneous instrument measured the object's true luminosity, distance, or composition, leaving open the possibility that a conventional light source or reflective object, imaged under unusual conditions, could produce a similar signature.
⚠  FORENSIC DATA PROFILE Schema v1.0 — Six-Domain Classification
01 Spatiotemporal Metrics Where & When
Precise Timestamp
Mid-April 2013 (exact calendar date never publicly disclosed); shadow-angle analysis of the surviving photograph places the time at approximately midday
Duration
Approximately two hours of continuous or intermittent visibility, per witness accounts relayed to CEFAA
Geographic Coordinates
Approx. 20.991°S, 68.639°W — Collahuasi mine, Rosario/Ujina pit area, Pica commune, Tarapacá Region, Chile
Location Typology
High-altitude Andean open-pit copper and molybdenum mining complex, approximately 4,200–4,300 m elevation, arid plateau
Sun / Moon Position
Daylight sighting; shadow analysis indicates a roughly midday solar position; not applicable to nighttime/lunar illumination
02 Observational Metrics The Five Observables (AATIP)
Anti-Gravity Lift
Speculative — reportedly held stationary or near-stationary for extended stretches with no visible means of support, but never instrumented or measured
Sudden Acceleration
Absent — described movements were slow, incremental repositioning in "short segments," not abrupt high-g bursts
Hypersonic Velocity
Absent — no velocity data of any kind exists; the object was largely stationary or slow-moving throughout
Low Observability
Absent — bright, colorful, and continuously visible in daylight to dozens of witnesses for two hours
Trans-Medium Travel
Absent — not claimed or observed; the object was seen only in open air
03 Physical & Morphological Metrics Appearance
Primary Shape
Flattened disc with a defined rim; CEFAA's filtered photo analysis distinguished a circular ring perimeter from a raised, hemispherical central structure; briefly described by witnesses as taking on a glowing, balloon-like form before reverting to a static disc
Luminosity & Color
Brilliant silvery/metallic; CEFAA's analysis found the luminosity pattern inconsistent with simple solar reflection, with an intense central point, four faint radiating rays, and light appearing to originate from the object's shadowed underside
Apparent Size
Estimated 5–10 meters in diameter by witnesses; not independently verified via triangulation or instrumented measurement
Estimated Altitude
Approximately 600 meters above the ground surface, per witness account; not confirmed by radar or any independent instrument
Acoustics
None reported; witnesses across the site described the object as completely silent
04 Environmental & Contextual Metrics The Surroundings
Atmospheric Conditions
Clear, cloudless sky confirmed by CEFAA's own consulting meteorologist, who independently ruled out lenticular cloud formation for the date and location
Radar Telemetry
None. Collahuasi is a private industrial site with no dedicated air-surveillance radar coverage; no radar data of any kind exists anywhere in the public record of this case
Air Traffic Logs
None published; CEFAA's review reportedly found no known experimental, conventional, or drone aircraft activity consistent with the sighting, but no specific flight-log or ATC correspondence has been made public
Space Triggers
None identified; no satellite re-entry, rocket launch, or space-debris event is documented as coinciding with the sighting
Lunar Illumination (Computed)
70% illuminated — Waning Gibbous, calculated from the reported date via synodic-month phase geometry (not sourced from any primary document)
Nearest Airport (Computed)
Coposa Airport (SCKP), approximately 27.2 km from this case's mapped location — a modern geographic reference point, not evidence the airport existed or was relevant at the time of the incident
Historical Weather (Computed)
Overcast, 2.3–14°C, 36% average cloud cover, 0mm precipitation — Open-Meteo / ERA5 reanalysis for this case's date and mapped coordinates, not a witness account
05 Forensic & Material Evidence Metrics Hard Proof
Multi-Spectrum Imagery
Two visible-light still photographs only, taken on a basic Samsung Kenox S860 compact digital camera; no infrared, UV, radar cross-section, or multi-spectral data exists
Electromagnetic Anomalies
None instrumented or measured; CEFAA's conclusion that the object was self-luminous rather than sunlight-reflective is an optical inference from two still images, not an electromagnetic-spectrum measurement
Physical Trace Data
None; no soil, vegetation, equipment, or other physical trace evidence was ever reported or collected at the mine site
Biological Impact
None reported
06 Witness & Data Credibility Metrics The Human Element
Observer Profile
Approximately 35 Collahuasi mine personnel reportedly observed the object; a core group of four technicians (electricity, electronics, and fluid-control specialists) tracked it, and one of them photographed it. No witness has ever been publicly named, and CEFAA was unable to arrange direct follow-up interviews with any of them
Sensory Type
Direct visual (daylight, naked-eye) across dozens of witnesses, corroborated by two still photographs from a single camera; no instrumented sensory data of any kind
Record Quality Score
57/100A real multi-witness daylight sighting with genuine photographic evidence and a documented government review scores in the middle of this site's range: held back by a roughly ten-month reporting delay before CEFAA ever saw the photographs, a single uncorroborated photographer and camera, witnesses who declined all direct follow-up contact with investigators, and the complete absence of radar, video, or any second independent camera.Rates how complete and reliable the record is. The credibility score at the top of the page is a separate judgment.
Investigation Status
Formally Closed / Unresolved — CEFAA's Own Published Conclusion: “An Object…Classified as a UFO”

The Conventional Explanation Candidate: What CEFAA Ruled Out, and What Remains

Unusually for a case in this catalog, the leading conventional-explanation work here was not performed by an outside skeptic or independent researcher after the fact — it was performed directly by the government agency investigating the case itself, as part of CEFAA's own standard process of elimination. That process addressed each of the obvious mundane candidates directly and specifically rather than in vague general terms, which is precisely why this file can rate each candidate individually rather than resorting to a single blanket dismissal.

A caveat on treating CEFAA's ruling-out as evidence of genuineness: CEFAA (Chile's official Committee for the Study of Anomalous Aerial Phenomena) is widely regarded as one of the more methodical state UAP bodies internationally, and this file gives its process-of-elimination work real credit for that reason — but ruling out the obvious mundane candidates is not the same as confirming an anomaly, and a government committee whose institutional purpose is studying unexplained aerial phenomena has an ordinary interest in cases that remain genuinely unexplained rather than in closing its own files. This site treats CEFAA's specific, checkable eliminations (the meteorologist's clear-sky finding, the international-affairs director's drone assessment) as strong evidence on their own technical merits, not because a government office's non-explanation should be read as pointing toward the exotic.

Atmospheric and Meteorological Candidates

CEFAA's own consulting meteorologist reviewed documented weather conditions for the date and location and specifically ruled out lenticular cloud formation — the single most common conventional explanation for disc-shaped sightings in mountainous terrain worldwide — on the strength of confirmed clear, cloudless sky conditions inconsistent with the moisture and wind-shear profile lenticular clouds require. No published account of the case raises sun dogs, ice-halo phenomena, or other atmospheric-optical effects as an alternative, and this file's own independent research found no detailed skeptical treatment proposing one; given the object's reported two-hour duration and controlled-looking vertical and horizontal repositioning, a static atmospheric-optical phenomenon would in any case be difficult to reconcile with the described behavior.

Drones and Known Aircraft

CEFAA's international affairs director addressed the drone hypothesis directly and specifically, noting that personnel in the mine's region were themselves familiar with drone operations and stating unambiguously that the object was “definitely not a drone.” Independently, this file notes a further technical point reinforcing that conclusion: no consumer, survey, or industrial drone commercially or militarily available in 2013 approached a 5–10 meter reported diameter, a scale that would place any drone explanation well outside anything realistically flown at a private mine site at that time. CEFAA's broader review additionally found no known experimental or conventional aircraft, and no military exercise, consistent with the object's reported position and behavior.

Weather Balloon

DGAC/CEFAA's review also ruled out weather balloons as an explanation. Independently, this file notes the reported behavior itself argues against a balloon explanation on its own terms: a free-flying balloon drifts largely in one direction under prevailing wind, and does not readily produce the repeated ascending, descending, and short-segment horizontal repositioning multiple witnesses described over a sustained two-hour period.

Photographic Hoax or Fabrication

This is the candidate this file treats with the most genuine caution, because the case's real evidentiary weaknesses — a single photographer, a roughly ten-month reporting delay, and witnesses who declined all direct cooperation with investigators — are exactly the conditions under which a hoax becomes easiest to construct and hardest to disprove. Weighed against that, CEFAA's own image analysts and the independent outside reviewer Bruce Maccabee both examined the photographs; the CEFAA analyst found an unidentified object, and Maccabee judged that the case “doesn't appear to be a hoax” while noting that the witnesses could not be questioned. Neither of those assessments amounts to definitive proof against a hoax — no forensic file-metadata analysis or original camera-file chain of custody has ever been published for this case — but it is the most honest, currently available answer to a serious and fair question.

Lenticular Cloud / Atmospheric-Optical Phenomenon

Implausible

Directly and specifically ruled out by CEFAA's own consulting meteorologist against documented clear, cloudless weather conditions for the date and location; the object's sustained two-hour duration and controlled-looking repositioning are also difficult to reconcile with a static optical or cloud phenomenon.

Consumer or Survey Drone

Implausible

Explicitly and directly ruled out by CEFAA's international affairs director, given local familiarity with drone operations; independently, no 2013-era drone approached the reported 5–10 meter scale of the object.

High-Altitude Weather Balloon

Implausible

Ruled out by DGAC/CEFAA's own review; a free-drifting balloon does not readily explain the reported repeated ascending, descending, and short-segment horizontal repositioning over two sustained hours.

Known or Experimental Aircraft

Implausible

Ruled out by officials, though no flight records behind that finding have been published; witnesses described the object as completely silent, unlike any known aircraft at that altitude.

Photographic Hoax or Fabrication

Inconclusive

A genuinely fair concern given the single uncorroborated photographer, a roughly ten-month reporting delay, and witnesses who declined direct investigator contact; weighed against CEFAA's own and an independent physicist's review of the images finding no sign of manipulation, though no forensic file-metadata analysis has ever been published.

Genuine Unidentified Phenomenon

Inconclusive

The conclusion of CEFAA's July 2014 study, which Bermúdez described as one analyst's determination, and the only characterization the investigating agency itself found consistent with all the available photographic and meteorological evidence — without the agency ever claiming to know the object's true origin or nature.

Related Cases

📄  DECLASSIFIED GOVERNMENT RECORDS Primary source documents from Chilean government archives

Confirmed Documents & Official Records

DGAC / CEFAA (Chile) "CEFAA: Un Modelo Investigativo de Fenómenos Aéreos Anómalos" 2021 (institutional history page)
DGAC.gob.cl — "CEFAA: Un Modelo Investigativo de Fenómenos Aéreos Anómalos" →

Chile's civil aviation authority's own published institutional history of CEFAA, covering its 1997 founding, its directors, its case-intake process, and its published transparency practices — the direct government source for how the agency that investigated Collahuasi actually operates.

DGAC (Chile) "Fenómenos Aéreos Anómalos y la Investigación Oficial en Chile" September 2019
DGAC.gob.cl — "Fenómenos Aéreos Anómalos y la Investigación Oficial en Chile" (2019) → (Download PDF)

DGAC's own official published booklet on Chile's institutional approach to anomalous aerial phenomena investigation, providing primary-source background on CEFAA's methodology and mandate.

SEFAA / DGAC (Chile) SEFAA Official Case Portal Ongoing since 2020
sefaa.dgac.gob.cl — Official CEFAA/SEFAA Site →

CEFAA's successor unit's current official web presence, publishing newly investigated and resolved cases quarterly since 2020 — a practice that began after the Collahuasi case, whose original 2013–2015 report predates this online archive and is documented instead through the agency's public statements and contemporaneous Chilean press coverage cited below.

Further Reading — Recommended Literature

📖

Confrontations: A Scientist's Search for Alien Contact

Jacques Vallee

Physicist and longtime UFO investigator Jacques Vallée's field investigations of forty international cases, including multiple Latin American sightings, offering methodological grounding for evaluating a photographed, multi-witness case like this one.

DISCLOSURE: Some links above are affiliate links. If you purchase through them, OverClassified receives a small commission at no additional cost to you. This helps support independent research.

Essential Viewing

Sources

  • The UFO Chronicles, "The Chilean Collahuasi UFO Case – Official Photographic Analysis/Report (English)," July 2014. theufochronicles.com →
  • Lee Speigel, HuffPost, "Did A UFO 'Not Made By Man' Hover Over Chile?" May 13, 2015. huffpost.com →
  • Leslie Kean, HuffPost, "Chile Releases Official Study on UFO Photos," July 4, 2014. huffpost.com →
  • Fox News, "Chile Investigates UFO Sighting In The Atacama Desert – 'Definitely Not A Drone,'" July 9, 2014. foxnews.com →
  • El Mostrador, "Difunden imagen de Ovni avistado en mina Collahuasi," July 1, 2014. elmostrador.cl →
  • La Tercera, "El extraño ovni de Collahuasi," June 29, 2014. latercera.com →
  • Univision Noticias, "Dirección de Aeronáutica reconoció oficialmente un ovni en Chile." univision.com →
  • BioBioChile, "Dirección de Aeronáutica Civil oficializa avistamiento de OVNI en el norte de Chile," July 7, 2014. biobiochile.cl →
  • La Voz del Norte, "Dirección General del Aeronáutica no tiene explicación para OVNI captado sobre mina Collahuasi," July 1, 2014. lavozdelnorte.cl →
  • Yibada, "Chile Concludes Flying Saucer Shaped Object Seen in 2013 Qualifies as a UFO," May 14, 2015. en.yibada.com →
  • RPP Noticias, "¿Un ovni en Chile? Científicos aseguran que sí y difunden imagen." rpp.pe →
  • "Informe ufológico del caso Collahuasi," presentation/report compilation. es.slideshare.net →
  • DGAC (Chile), "CEFAA: Un Modelo Investigativo de Fenómenos Aéreos Anómalos." dgac.gob.cl →
  • DGAC (Chile), "Fenómenos Aéreos Anómalos y la Investigación Oficial en Chile," official publication, September 2019. dgac.gob.cl →
  • SEFAA (Chile), official CEFAA successor case portal. sefaa.dgac.gob.cl →
  • Wikipedia, "Collahuasi mine," used for cross-checking ownership, coordinates, elevation, and production data against primary sources. en.wikipedia.org →
  • Wikimedia Commons, File:Mina de Collahuasi, Chile, 2016-02-10, DD 30.JPG, by Diego Delso (CC BY-SA 4.0) — source of this case file's hero image. commons.wikimedia.org →
  • YouTube, CHV Noticias, "Dirección de Aeronáutica reconoció oficialmente un OVNI en Chile." youtube.com →
  • YouTube, "Impactante avistamiento de ovni en Collahuasi." youtube.com →
  • Patricio Abusleme, UFOs in Chile: Chronicles of Real Encounters with Unidentified Flying Objects and Their Alleged Occupants — national context for Chile's broader UFO-reporting history.
  • Diana Espírito Santo, UFOs, the Absurd, and the Limit of Anthropological Knowledge: Imagining the Impossible in Chile (Routledge) — scholarly context on Chilean ufology.
  • John Scott Chace, UFOs In Central and South American AirSpace — regional context for South American UFO reporting.
  • Leslie Kean, UFOs: Generals, Pilots, and Government Officials Go on the Record (Harmony Books) — methodological context for government-official UFO testimony.
  • Jacques Vallée, Confrontations: A Scientist's Search for Alien Contact (Ballantine Books) — methodological context for field investigation of international, including Latin American, UFO cases.

Corrections (October 2026)

A fact-check against the CEFAA report (Scott Corrales's English translation), Leslie Kean's July 2014 HuffPost report, La Tercera (June 29, 2014), El Mostrador and BioBioChile (July 2014), Fox News (July 9, 2014) and HuffPost (May 13, 2015) found that an earlier version of this page attributed to Ricardo Bermúdez a quote no source contains (the clause about “vertical and horizontal movements no airplane can perform”), invented his description of “several analysts” and skeptical scientists, and omitted his actual caution that the UFO finding was “the determination of only one CEFFA analyst among several.” The page had also described a “year-long multi-disciplinary review” (the study was released July 3, 2014, about four months after the February 22 report), said four technicians photographed the object (one technician did), cut Bruce Maccabee's quote before his caveat about the unquestioned witnesses, and presented the 2015 “qualifies as a UFO” coverage as a new DGAC conclusion. These passages have been corrected. Reports differ on the witness count (35 in the Chilean press, four technicians in Kean and the CEFAA report) and the duration (about two hours in the Chilean press, more than an hour in Kean); both figures are now given.

Following this review, the rating was changed from Credible 64 to Disputed 50 (October 27, 2026), because the higher rating had rested partly on claims corrected or removed above.

🔍 View more images of this case on Google →

See something inaccurate? Have additional information or sources?

Suggest an Edit →

Last Updated: November 16, 2026